Family law guide

Published Last reviewed 13 mins read 11 sections

Part of: Financial Settlement after Divorce

A Hadkinson order stops a person who is deliberately breaking a court order from pursuing their own case, or part of it, until they put the breach right. Many separated people know the situation. Your ex has stopped paying what the court ordered, or will not hand over financial disclosure. Yet they ask the same court to reduce what they owe. The order takes its name from Hadkinson v Hadkinson, a 1952 Court of Appeal case. Judges today treat it as a measure of last resort. This guide explains when the court will make one, how to apply, and why enforcement usually comes first.

Key takeaways

  • It shuts the door until they comply. The person in breach cannot go on with their own application or appeal. First they must pay, or do what the order required.
  • It is not a punishment. The Court of Appeal calls it a case management order of last resort, not a penalty for contempt (Assoun v Assoun [2017] EWCA Civ 21, para 3).
  • A judge applies five tests. They look for a deliberate, continuing breach that impedes justice, no other remedy, and an order that goes no further than needed (P v R [2026] EWHC 2359 (Fam), para 32).
  • Enforce first. If ordinary enforcement can get the money in, expect a refusal. The order is not “enforcement by the back door”.
  • Children cases are harder. Where a child’s welfare is at stake, the court must also find that the order serves the child.

Is your ex ignoring an order and still asking the court for help? Book a free initial consultation to talk through your next step with one of our specialists.

What is a Hadkinson order in family law?

It is an order that refuses to hear a party while they remain in contempt by failing to obey a court order. Sometimes the judge hears them only on conditions instead. Typical conditions are paying the arrears, paying a sum into court, or giving full disclosure by a fixed date. Until then, their own application goes no further.

The courts describe it as draconian, because it goes straight to a person’s right of access to a court. In Assoun v Assoun, Sir Ernest Ryder said such an order “is not and should not be a commonplace”. He called it a case management order of last resort in cases such as a financial remedy claim (para 3). Later, in De Gafforj v De Gafforj [2018] EWCA Civ 2070, the Court of Appeal added that it is not “enforcement by the back door” (quoted in P v R, para 33).

That separates it from committal. Committal punishes a breach and can lead to a fine or prison. Our guide to committal proceedings in the family court explains that route. This order punishes nothing. It simply pauses the case of the person in breach until they comply. People call this needing to purge their contempt first.

Where does Hadkinson v Hadkinson come from?

It began as a children case. A mother took her son to Australia in breach of an order preventing his removal. She then failed to return him when the judge ordered her to. When she tried to appeal, the Court of Appeal refused to hear her until she had put that right (P v R, para 35).

Denning LJ explained the limits. Disobeying an order does not, by itself, stop a person being heard. But disobedience can impede the course of justice, for example by making it harder for the court to find the truth or enforce its orders. Then the court may refuse to hear that person until they remove the obstacle. He added that refusing to hear a party “is only to be justified by grave considerations of public policy” (P v R, paras 30 and 35). Those two ideas, impediment and restraint, still run through every Hadkinson application today.

When will the court make a Hadkinson order?

Only when all five tests are met. The Court of Appeal set them out in De Gafforj, building on Mubarak v Mubarik [2004] EWHC 1158 (Fam). The High Court applied them again in June 2026 (P v R, para 32). The person applying has to show that:

  1. the other party is in contempt, because they have not complied with an order
  2. the contempt is deliberate and continuing, by someone well able to comply if they chose to (Assoun, para 13, approving Laing v Laing)
  3. as a result, there is an impediment to the course of justice
  4. there is no other realistic and effective remedy
  5. the order is proportionate and goes no further than necessary

In a children case there is a sixth question: whether the order is consistent with the child’s welfare (P v R, paras 36 and 39). The judge decides the facts on the balance of probabilities, the civil standard, not the criminal one (Assoun, para 31).

Could a Hadkinson order stop your ex’s application?

Answer four questions and the five tests below fill in for your situation. You will see the points in your favour, the open questions and the gaps. Nothing you choose is saved or sent anywhere.

1. What has your ex not done?
2. Could they comply if they chose to?
3. What are they asking the court for?
4. Have you tried to enforce the order?

The five tests a judge will apply

Answer the questions above and each test shows how your facts measure up.

  1. In breach of an orderWaiting for question 1.
  2. Deliberate and continuingWaiting for question 2.
  3. An impediment to justiceWaiting for question 1.
  4. No other effective remedyWaiting for question 4.
  5. ProportionateWaiting for question 3.
The call this check cannot makeWhether your evidence of their means and conduct is strong enough, and which conditions to ask the judge for, depends on the papers in your case.

Book a free initial consultation

Based on Assoun v Assoun [2017] EWCA Civ 21 and P v R [2026] EWHC 2359 (Fam). A judge decides every application on its own facts.

Your ex is in breach but wants the order reduced: what can you do?

You can ask the court to stay their application until they comply. This is the classic setting for a Hadkinson order. In Assoun v Assoun, a husband who owed large arrears under a periodical payments order applied to have it reduced or discharged. The judge ruled that he could not proceed until he had paid what he owed. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision. It found the order was the only one left that might secure compliance (Assoun, paras 3 and 39).

The same case is a warning about procedure. The wife had raised the request in a skeleton argument one working day before the hearing, with no formal application or evidence. The Court of Appeal said future applicants should use an application notice under Part 18 of the Family Procedure Rules. It should state the order sought and the reasons, rely on evidence verified by a statement of truth, and be served properly. Courts may refuse or adjourn an application that ignores the rules (Assoun, paras 16 and 18).

Your evidence should show the breach, the means to comply and the effect on the case. A schedule of what fell due and when, their Form E and any later disclosure of income or spending usually do most of that work.

Hadkinson order or enforcement: which comes first?

In most cases, enforcement comes first. The fourth test asks whether any other realistic and effective remedy exists, and ordinary enforcement usually is one. You can apply for a specific method, or ask the court to choose the method it considers appropriate. If you ask the court to choose, it orders the person who owes the money to attend court and complete a financial statement (FPR rule 33.3). Our guide to enforcing financial court orders sets out the methods.

P v R shows how this plays out. A mother asked the court to bar a father who had not paid a £26,000 costs order. She had already obtained an interim third party debt order in the County Court, which froze around £11,600 in his bank accounts. He was offering a payment plan. Mr Justice MacDonald found none of the tests met and refused the application. Enforcement was already working. Using the bar to get faster payment than the enforcing court would allow would be enforcement by the back door (P v R, paras 28, 47, 53-54 and 63).

Where the breach is a refusal to give disclosure, the picture can differ. Without the figures, the court cannot decide the case fairly at all, and that is the impediment Denning LJ had in mind.

Can a Hadkinson order be made in a children case or an appeal?

Yes, but the bar is higher. Hadkinson itself concerned a child. Today the court must also ask whether the order is consistent with the child’s welfare (P v R, paras 35 and 36). An order that would stop the court considering what a child needs is unlikely to be made.

In P v R the father’s appeal against an order ending direct contact had been given permission on three grounds. The judge held that blocking the appeal over an unpaid costs order would cause the very delay the Children Act 1989 warns against. It was not in the child’s interests (paras 57-60). The Court of Appeal has also said that permission to appeal is relevant but does not decide the question (Ahmed & Anor v Faraj [2025] EWCA Civ 468, summarised in P v R, para 34). If you are weighing an appeal yourself, see our guide to grounds for appeal in the family court.

What if you are the one facing a Hadkinson application?

Take it seriously and answer it with evidence. If you can comply, doing so ends the problem. If you genuinely cannot, the question is whether your breach is deliberate. The court looks for a breach by someone well able to comply (Assoun, para 13). Saying you cannot pay is not enough on its own, so your disclosure has to show it. And a real argument for reducing the order does not excuse non-payment in the meantime if you have the means (Assoun, para 13, quoting Laing v Laing).

Hadkinson order in a financial case: a toy house on a pile of coins beside a Family Court financial statement
An order your ex will not obey can feel worthless. The court has ways to make it count.

We regularly advise and assist people whose former partner has stopped complying with a financial order. In one matter, an ex-husband stopped paying the maintenance ordered on the divorce. He then applied to have it cut, saying his income had fallen. His own bank statements showed regular foreign holidays and a new car on finance. We helped his former wife set the arrears against that spending in a single schedule. We also helped her prepare an application on notice asking the court to pause his case until he paid. Every case turns on its own facts.

Expert Tip

Before you apply, build one page for the judge. List every payment or step the order required, the date it fell due, what actually happened, and the evidence of their means on that date. Then add a line for each enforcement step you have tried and its result. You are asking for an order the courts call draconian. Make it easy to see, test by test, that the breach is deliberate and that nothing less will work.

Iblal Iqbal, Partner & Family Law Strategist

Hadkinson order: frequently asked questions

Is being barred from court a punishment for contempt?

No. The Court of Appeal describes it as a case management order of last resort, not a penalty for contempt. If you want the breach punished, committal proceedings are the route. The bar only pauses the case of the person in breach until they comply.

Who can make a Hadkinson application?

The other party to the case, usually the person owed money or waiting for disclosure. They use a Part 18 application notice stating the order sought and the reasons. It needs supporting evidence and must be served on the person in breach.

Can a Hadkinson application be made without notice?

Only where there are real grounds for urgency. In Assoun v Assoun the Court of Appeal said applicants should follow the Part 18 procedure on notice. Courts may refuse or adjourn an application that does not comply with the rules.

What standard of proof applies to a Hadkinson application?

The civil standard, the balance of probabilities. The order is a case management order, so the judge makes the findings to that standard. The criminal standard used in committal proceedings does not apply.

How long can the court refuse to hear the person in breach?

It is not a permanent ban. It pauses the case of the person in breach only until they purge their contempt. They do that by paying or doing what the order required, on whatever conditions the judge has set.

Does permission to appeal stop a Hadkinson application?

Not automatically. The Court of Appeal confirmed in 2025 that permission to appeal is relevant when the court decides whether to make the order. It is not decisive on its own.

Ex ignoring the order and still asking the court for more?

Two things go wrong with a Hadkinson order. People apply too early, before trying ordinary enforcement, and the judge refuses because another remedy was available. Or they raise it informally at a hearing, without a proper application and evidence, and the court will not deal with it.

A free initial consultation is a conversation with a specialist, who gives you initial advice tailored to your circumstances. It does not include drafting or reviewing documents. If you can, have the date of the order and a note of what has not been paid or done to hand.

Book a free initial consultation or call 0330 094 5880.

You can also read our guides to financial settlement after divorce and spousal maintenance.

General information about the law in England and Wales, not advice on your circumstances.

Written by

Garry Steedman is a family law consultant at Kabir Family Law, specialising in complex divorce, children and property disputes, including TOLATA claims for unmarried couples and cohabitees. He advises on high‑conflict separations, contested children matters and financial settlements, combining clear, straightforward guidance with practical strategies that help clients move forward with confidence. Garry also supports the wider technical trusts of land issues, reviewing complex case files and helping to advise on robust evidence for court and negotiations.

Related Services

8 of 20 guides — scroll sideways for more

Our videos

Short videos from the Kabir Family Law team, explaining family law in plain English.

View all

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting