Success story
Published 10 mins read11 sections

A father heard that his former partner’s new boyfriend had been violent towards previous partners. The man had just moved into the home where the father’s two children spent most of their week. He asked our family law specialists about Clare’s Law and child contact, and how to keep his children safe without losing his time with them. This is an anonymised account.

A warning about the man living with his children

The parents had separated some years earlier. The children lived mainly with their mother and stayed with their father every other weekend and one evening a week. No court had ever been involved.

The warning came second-hand, and our client had no proof. He feared that raising it would look like jealousy and might cost him his time with the children. Our guide to stopping contact on safety grounds explains when those concerns can justify changing arrangements.

What the law says about Clare’s Law and child contact

Clare’s Law is the common name for the Domestic Violence Disclosure Scheme. It lets the police share information about a person’s previous violent or abusive offending where this may help protect a partner or ex-partner, and any relevant children.

Under the “right to ask”, a member of the public can apply to the police. That includes someone concerned for the person at risk, such as a friend or relative. Under the “right to know”, the police decide for themselves to disclose.

The police make the final decision. They disclose to the person best placed to protect the one at risk, normally that person, so the parent who asks may not be the one they tell. Whoever they tell is asked to keep the information confidential and use it only to keep that person and any children safe.

The scheme’s guidance is statutory. Section 77 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 requires the Secretary of State to issue guidance on police disclosure to prevent domestic abuse, and chief officers of police must have regard to it.

If parents cannot agree about contact, the court decides under the Children Act 1989, with the child’s welfare as its paramount consideration under section 1(1). In an opposed case, the welfare checklist in section 1(3) includes any harm the child has suffered or is at risk of suffering. Practice Direction 12J adds that living in a home where domestic abuse happens harms children or puts them at risk.

How we advised him to use the right to ask

If he ever thought the children were in immediate danger, he should call 999. Otherwise, the right to ask was the measured step. We advised him to apply himself, as someone concerned for the mother and the children.

We helped him write down only what he knew, such as who told him and when the partner moved in. Leaving out guesses made his account easier for the police to check. He applied online that week, with our guidance.

We also prepared him for the police telling the mother instead, as the person best placed to protect herself and the children. They would not tell him whether they had.

Meanwhile, we advised him to keep the existing arrangements running and not to confront the mother or her partner, which could raise the risk at home. We also helped him write a proposal for later: handovers at school, and the children never left in the partner’s care.

Finally, we explained the court route if agreement failed. Under section 8, a child arrangements order sets with whom, and when, a child lives or spends time. A prohibited steps order can stop anyone taking a specified step, of a kind a parent could take, without the court’s consent. As a parent, he could apply for either on form C100 without permission, under section 10(4).

A disclosure to the mother, and safer arrangements

Weeks later, the mother called him. The police had spoken to her, she said, and children’s social care were involved. He did not ask what she had learned, and she did not say.

By then the partner had moved out at her request, and a social worker was helping her with a safety plan. She asked whether the children could stay with their father more while things settled.

The parents agreed in writing that the children would not spend time with the man. Handovers moved to school, and the father gained an extra evening each week and longer weekends. Neither parent needed to go to court.

Every case turns on its own facts, so this is not a promise about any other family.

What you can take from Clare’s Law and child contact

If you hear that a new partner around your children has a violent past, use the right to ask. Be ready for the police to tell the other parent instead, which can still protect your children.

Keep any proposal focused on the children’s care. Read more in our guide to the Clare’s Law scheme and our page on a prohibited steps order, and see how we prepare these success stories.

“The right to ask can feel like sending a question into silence: any disclosure goes to whoever can best protect the person at risk, and that may not be you. Keep your application short and factual, and do not ask the children about the new partner. The Domestic Abuse Act 2021 treats a child who sees, hears or experiences the effects of abuse, and is related to either adult, as a victim, so plan overnight stays early.”

Hannah Overton, Complex Children Specialist, Kabir Family Law

Talk it through with us

If you have heard a warning about a new partner around your children, book a free initial consultation. It is confidential and carries no obligation. Tell us what you know, and our family law specialists will explain your options.

The legal issue

Separated parents shared parental responsibility for their two children, who lived mainly with their mother and stayed with their father every other weekend and one evening a week. No court order had ever been made. The father heard second-hand that the mother's new partner, who had just moved into the children's home, had been violent towards former partners. He had no proof, and he feared that raising it would look like jealousy and cost him his time with the children.

The law this rests on

  • Domestic Violence Disclosure Scheme (Clare's Law), Home Office statutory guidance: under the "right to ask", a member of the public, including someone concerned for the person at risk such as a friend or relative, can apply to the police. Under the "right to know", the police decide for themselves to disclose information to protect someone.
  • Domestic Violence Disclosure Scheme guidance: the final decision on disclosure rests with the police. A disclosure is made to the person best placed to safeguard the person at risk, which will normally be that person, so the applicant may not be the one told. Where the applicant is not the recipient, the applicant is not told whether a disclosure has been or will be made. The person told is asked to agree that the information is confidential and must use it only to safeguard the person at risk and any relevant children.
  • Domestic Abuse Act 2021 s.77: the Secretary of State must issue guidance to chief officers of police about disclosing police information to prevent domestic abuse, and each chief officer must have regard to it. The Home Office states that this section places the Domestic Violence Disclosure Scheme guidance on a statutory footing.
  • Children Act 1989 s.1(1): the child's welfare is the court's paramount consideration.
  • Children Act 1989 s.1(3)(e): where an application is opposed, the welfare checklist includes any harm the child has suffered or is at risk of suffering.
  • Children Act 1989 s.8(1): a child arrangements order regulates with whom and when a child lives, spends time or otherwise has contact. A prohibited steps order prevents a specified step, of a kind a parent could take, being taken without the court's consent.
  • Children Act 1989 s.10(4)(a): a parent is entitled to apply for a section 8 order.
  • Practice Direction 12J, paragraph 4: domestic abuse is harmful to children, or puts them at risk of harm, including where they live in a home in which domestic abuse is perpetrated.

How we approached it

We told him to call 999 at once if he ever believed the children were in immediate danger. Nothing suggested that, so we advised him to use the right to ask as someone concerned for the mother and the children. We helped him write down only what he knew, without guesses, and he applied online with our guidance. We prepared him for the police to speak to the mother rather than to him, and for them not to tell him whether they had disclosed anything. We advised him to keep the existing arrangements running and not to confront the mother or her partner, and we helped him write a child-focused proposal for later: handovers at school, and the children never left in the partner's care. We also explained the court route on form C100 if agreement failed.

The outcome

A few weeks later the mother told him the police had spoken to her and that children's social care were involved. She did not share the details, and he did not ask. She had asked the partner to move out and was working with a social worker on a safety plan. The parents agreed in writing that the children would not spend time with the man, that handovers would move to school and that the father would have an extra evening each week and longer weekends. Neither parent needed to go to court. Every case turns on its own facts, and this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from this

  • If you hear that a new partner around your children has a violent past, call 999 if there is immediate danger and otherwise use the right to ask.
  • The right to ask is open to people concerned about someone else, such as a friend or relative.
  • The police decide whether to disclose and to whom, and it may be the other parent rather than you. You may not even be told whether a disclosure was made.
  • Disclosed information is confidential and may only be used to keep the person at risk and any children safe.
  • Avoid confrontation and keep any proposal focused on the children's care, such as handovers and who looks after them.
  • If agreement fails, a parent can apply on form C100 for a child arrangements order or a prohibited steps order, and the court treats the child's welfare as paramount.

Checked and approved for publication by Iblal Iqbal.

Last reviewed .

Read more about this area of family law

Reasons To Stop Child Contact

Author:

Hannah Overton is a complex children specialist at Kabir Family Law, focusing on child arrangements disputes, fact‑finding hearings and cases involving CAFCASS and safeguarding concerns in the family courts of England and Wales. She has extensive experience supporting parents through allegation‑heavy proceedings and creates clear, practical resources that explain court processes, evidence preparation and contact arrangements. Hannah also works closely with the client services team to ensure families receive informed, compassionate guidance at every stage of their case.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting