After more than thirty years of marriage, her husband applied for a divorce. She had stayed at home to raise their children, now adults, while he worked and built up the main pension. With retirement a few years away, she faced a grey divorce. Her worry was whether she would have enough to live on for the rest of her life. This anonymised account explains how our family law specialists advised her.
A grey divorce close to retirement
He proposed selling the house and splitting the money equally as settlement of the grey divorce. He would keep his pension and pay her maintenance until he retired. She had almost no pension and had not worked for decades. Half the house would not buy her a home outright, and a large mortgage was unlikely at her age. He also planned to apply for the final order as soon as the law allowed.
What the law says about divorce later in life
When a court decides money on divorce, section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 tells it to look at all the circumstances. Section 25(2) lists the factors, including each spouse’s income, earning capacity, needs, ages and the length of the marriage. Paragraph (f) treats looking after the home or caring for the family as a contribution, so her years at home counted.
Section 25B(1) brings in pension benefits a spouse has or is likely to have. Section 25(2)(h) adds any benefit a spouse will lose the chance of acquiring because of the divorce, such as a widow’s pension. The Act sets no fixed split.
Why the order of steps mattered
His scheme paid a widow’s pension only to a surviving spouse, so a grey divorce would end her claim to it. Section 10 protects a respondent in her position. If she applied under section 10(2), the court must not make the divorce final unless it is satisfied that he need not provide for her, or that what he has provided is reasonable and fair or the best that can be made.
In deciding that, the court must consider her position if he dies first. It may still make the divorce final where there is a reason not to wait, but only if he gives a satisfactory undertaking to make the provision it approves. Meanwhile, under section 24B(2), a pension sharing order cannot take effect until the divorce is final.
What our family law specialists advised
We started with timing. Once the conditional order was made, she applied under section 10(2), with our guidance, so the final order would wait for the finances.
Next, we advised her to put income first. A pension pays for life, while cash from a house sale can only be spent once. We helped her ask for full disclosure, including a current valuation of his pension. We also suggested she check her State Pension forecast on GOV.UK. His was a defined benefit scheme, so we advised a single pensions expert, instructed jointly. We helped her frame the main question: what pension share would give them similar incomes in retirement?
She wanted a smaller home near her children that she could buy without a mortgage following the grey divorce. We helped her gather property listings and a budget for later life, which showed what she would need under section 25(2)(b). We also advised her to aim for a clean break, which section 25A(1) requires the court to consider, once her pension income was secure. Maintenance that stopped at his retirement would have left her with a gap.
The outcome
The expert’s report showed that an equal split of capital would leave her with a far lower retirement income than his. After two rounds of offers, which she made with our guidance, the couple agreed terms. They would sell the house, and she would take the larger share of the equity, enough to buy a smaller home outright. A pension sharing order would give her a percentage of his scheme, using the expert’s figures. They also agreed a clean break.
Both signed the consent order, she sent it to the court, and a judge approved it. Only then did her husband apply for the final order, and the pension share could not take effect before the divorce was final. Every case turns on its own facts, so this is not a promise about any other family.
What to take from this if you face a grey divorce
Settle the finances before the final order, especially where a survivor’s pension is at stake. If your spouse applied for the grey divorce, ask about section 10. Value pensions properly, because a transfer value is only a starting point. Plan, too, for the home you will need in ten or twenty years.
Our guide to pension sharing orders explains how a share works, and our article on pension rights after a long marriage covers survivor benefits and the State Pension. Our financial settlement after divorce guide covers every stage. You can also read how we prepare these success stories.
“Test every offer against one question: what would you live on if your spouse died first? Ordinary maintenance ends on the death of either of you, or if you remarry. A pension share gives you a credit in your own name against the scheme, so the income it buys does not depend on how long your spouse lives. Ask when that income could start, because the years between the settlement and that date need a plan of their own.”
Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law
Talk to us about a grey divorce
If you are facing a grey divorce after a long marriage, talk to us before the final order is made. A free initial consultation is confidential and carries no obligation. Bring what you know about the pensions and the home, and our family law specialists will explain your options and the order to take them in.
The legal issue
A couple had been married for more than thirty years and were both close to retirement. The wife had stayed at home to raise their children, now adults, and had almost no pension of her own. The husband had worked throughout and held the main pension, a defined benefit scheme. He applied for a divorce and proposed selling the home, splitting the money equally, keeping his pension and paying maintenance only until he retired. He also planned to apply for the final order as soon as the law allowed.
The law this rests on
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(1): the court must have regard to all the circumstances of the case, first consideration being given to the welfare of any child of the family under eighteen.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(a): the income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources each party has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(b): the financial needs, obligations and responsibilities of each party.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(d): the age of each party and the duration of the marriage.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(f): contributions to the welfare of the family, including looking after the home or caring for the family.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(h): the value of any benefit a party will lose the chance of acquiring because of the divorce.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25B(1): the s.25(2) matters include pension benefits a party has or is likely to have, and pension benefits a party will lose the chance of acquiring because of the divorce; for pension benefits, s.25(2)(a) applies as if the words "in the foreseeable future" were omitted.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.10(2) and (3): where a conditional order has been made in favour of one party (or of both, where one has since withdrawn) and the respondent applies for consideration of their financial position after the divorce, the court must not make the divorce order final unless satisfied that no provision should be required, or that the provision made is reasonable and fair or the best that can be made. s.10(4): the court may, if it thinks fit, still make the order final where circumstances make that desirable without delay and it has obtained a satisfactory undertaking from the applicant to make such financial provision as the court may approve.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.10(3A): the court must consider all the circumstances, including the age, health, conduct, earning capacity, financial resources and financial obligations of each party, and the respondent's financial position if the applicant dies first.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.21A(1): a pension sharing order specifies the percentage value of one party's pension rights to be transferred for the benefit of the other.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.24B(1) and (2): the court may make a pension sharing order on or after making a divorce order, but it does not take effect until the divorce order has been made final.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25A(1): the court must consider whether the financial obligations of each party towards the other should end as soon after the divorce as it considers just and reasonable.
How we approached it
We advised her on timing first. His scheme paid a widow's pension only to a surviving spouse, so a final divorce order would end her claim to it. Once the conditional order was made, she applied under Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.10(2), with our guidance, so the court would consider her financial position before making the divorce final.
We advised her to put income in retirement first. We helped her ask for full financial disclosure, including an up to date valuation of his pension, and suggested she check her State Pension forecast. Because his was a defined benefit scheme, we advised a single pensions expert, chosen and paid for by both spouses, and helped her frame the main question: what pension share would give them similar incomes in retirement?
We helped her gather property listings and a later-life budget to show her housing and income needs under s.25(2)(b), and advised her to aim for a clean break once her pension income was secure. We guided her through each round of offers.
The outcome
The expert's report showed that an equal split of capital would have left her with a far lower retirement income than his. With our guidance, the couple agreed terms. They would sell the home and she would take the larger share of the equity, enough to buy a smaller home outright. A pension sharing order gave her a percentage of his scheme, set using the expert's figures, and both agreed to a clean break. Both signed the consent order, she sent it to the court and a judge approved it. Only then did her husband apply for the final order, and the pension share could not take effect before it was made (s.24B(2)). Every case turns on its own facts, and this is not a promise about any other family.
What to take from this
- Get the order of steps right. If your spouse applied for the divorce, ask about Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.10(2) before the final order is made.
- A pension sharing order cannot take effect until the divorce order is final (s.24B(2)), so settle the money first.
- The court must have regard to pension benefits, including any a spouse will lose the chance of acquiring because of the divorce, such as a survivor's pension (s.25(2)(h) and s.25B(1)).
- Years spent looking after the home or caring for the family count as a contribution (s.25(2)(f)).
- The Act sets no fixed split. Have pensions valued properly and ask what a share means as income for life.
- Plan for a home you can afford in later life, ideally without a large mortgage.
Checked and approved for publication by Garry Steedman.
Last reviewed .