Family law guide

Published Last reviewed 12 mins read 10 sections

Part of: Financial Consent Order

A consent order rejected by the judge has not been approved yet, and the agreement behind it may still go through once you answer what the court raised. A judge who thinks the terms are unfair can ask you to change them, says GOV.UK’s guidance on applying for a consent order. The court can also ask for more information or call you both to a hearing, and each of those needs a different reply. This guide explains why judges send agreed orders back, how to reply and what happens if one of you will no longer agree. It forms part of our guide to the financial consent order and covers the law in England and Wales.

Key takeaways

  • A returned order is not a final refusal. If the judge does not think the terms are fair, they can ask you to change them (GOV.UK).
  • The court can approve agreed terms on the papers alone, unless it has reason to inquire further (Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, s.33A).
  • New terms need a new signed draft. The application must include the draft order with the respondent’s signed agreement (FPR r.9.26(1)(a)).
  • Some returns are about paperwork, such as a missing signature or pension annex. No judge can approve any consent order before the conditional order.
  • If you can no longer agree, either of you can ask the court to decide, usually after a mediation meeting.

Has the court sent your agreement back? You can book a free initial consultation for initial advice from one of our specialists before you reply.

It means a judge has read your agreed terms and is not ready to approve them yet. Instead, the court wants something from you first: an explanation, a change to the terms, a corrected document or your attendance at a hearing.

Consent orders are normally dealt with on paper. GOV.UK says there is usually no hearing, and a judge approves the order if they think it is fair. Until that happens, your agreement is not a court order, so neither of you can enforce it yet. Pulling out of a signed deal can still have consequences, as our guide to the Xydhias agreement explains. The order also only takes effect once the final order ends your marriage or civil partnership. Our guide to the sealed consent order explains what happens after approval.

A judge sends an agreed order back when the papers leave a question the court has to answer before approving it. Either a document is missing or wrong, or the terms look unfair against the factors the law tells the court to weigh.

The court must look at all the circumstances of your case. Its first consideration is the welfare of any child of the family under 18 (MCA 1973, s.25(1)). It then weighs each person’s income, resources, needs, age and contributions, among other factors (s.25(2)). Section 33A lets the judge rely on the information you filed. However, that only holds while nothing in it gives the judge a reason to look further. So a gap between the figures and the split you chose can prompt a question.

When a consent order is rejected on paper, start with what your papers left unexplained. Our D81 form guide sets out the questions a judge asks of your statement of information.

Five faults come straight from the rules and guidance. Each one can stop a judge approving the order until you put it right, however fair the terms are.

Paperwork faults and what the rules require
The faultWhat is requiredWhere it says so
An unsigned draftTwo copies of the draft order, one signed by the respondent to show agreementFPR r.9.26(1)(a)
Statement of information signed by one of youBoth of you sign a joint form, or each signs the other’s formFPR r.9.26(2) and (3)
Undertakings signed only by a lawyerThe person giving an undertaking signs the statement of agreement tooPD9A, para 7.1
A pension order with no annexAn annex for each pension arrangement, referred to in the body of the orderFPR r.9.35
A pension attachment the scheme was never sentThe pension scheme is sent the application, the draft order and the pension detailsFPR r.9.34(2)

The rules on drafts and signatures are in Part 9 of the Family Procedure Rules, and the rule on undertakings is in Practice Direction 9A. An undertaking is a formal promise to the court. Timing matters too: GOV.UK says the court cannot approve a consent order before the conditional order. If a pension is part of the deal, our guide to the pension sharing order explains how a share works.

Consent order rejected: a woman at her laptop works through the judge's questions, with the financial papers beside her
Read the judge’s note point by point before you write a word of the reply.

Your route depends on three things: what the court sent back, whether you both still agree, and whether anything has changed. Answer each question and your reply plan fills in, one line at a time. Nothing you choose leaves this page. The plan shows how replies usually start and is not advice on your case.

1. What did the court send back?
2. Do you both still stand by the agreement?
3. Has anything changed since you both signed?

Your reply plan

  • What the court is asking for

    Pick what the court sent back to see what the judge is asking you for, and the rule behind it.

    Facts or reasons your papers did not give. A judge can approve on what you filed unless something prompts a closer look (s.33A).

    Different terms. The order must be in terms you both agree, so a judge can invite a change but cannot impose one (s.33A(3)).

    Your reasons, in person. Neither of you normally has to attend, so a direction to attend means questions need answers (FPR r.9.26(4)).

    A corrected document, such as a signature or a pension annex. Put that item right and send it back with a short covering note.

  • Your route from here

    Say whether you both still agree to see if you can reply together or need another route.

    Reply together. If the terms change, send a fresh draft you both sign.

    Settle the reply between you first. A reply one of you has not seen can reopen the deal.

    Talk again first. If that fails, either of you can ask the court to decide, usually after a mediation meeting.

  • Before you reply

    Say whether any figures have moved since you signed to see what to update first.

    Update the figures first. A reply built on old values invites new questions.

    Make every figure in your reply match the draft order and your statement of information.

The judgement call in your reply

Answer all three questions to see the decision your reply turns on.

Whether an explanation will satisfy the court, or the terms need to move.

How far to go to meet the court’s concern without losing what you agreed.

Whether to renegotiate or let the court decide, and what each route costs.

Book a free initial consultation

How do you answer the judge's questions?

Answer every point the judge raised in one reply, and send any document it needs with it. If the terms change, send a fresh draft order that you have both signed.

A consent order rejected by the judge for a paperwork fault is the simplest to put right. Correct the document, make sure both of you have signed where the rules require, and send it back.

When the judge asks for information

Give the court the facts the papers left out, and explain how they make the split fair. For example, one of you may take most of the savings because the other keeps a larger pension. A short written explanation, with figures that match your statement of information, can answer the point. After that, the judge can approve the terms you already agreed.

When the judge asks for changes

Decide together whether you accept the change. If you do, redraft the order and both sign it again, because the court needs the respondent's signed agreement to the terms (FPR r.9.26(1)(a)). Change only what the judge raised. Reopening other terms gives the court a new set of questions to ask.

When the judge lists a hearing

Go, and prepare to explain the deal. The rules say neither of you needs to attend a consent order hearing unless the court directs otherwise (r.9.26(4)). So when the court does direct it, the judge wants to hear your reasons in person. Bring the draft order, your statement of information and any figures that support the split.

We advised a mother whose agreed order came back from the court with one question: why was she taking most of the savings? The papers never mentioned that her husband was keeping a pension worth considerably more. We helped her set out that trade in a short explanation, with matching figures in the statement of information, and her husband agreed the wording before it went back. The judge then approved the terms they had agreed. Each judge weighs the whole picture, so no two cases run the same way.

Can the judge rewrite what you agreed?

No. A consent order is an order in the terms applied for, to which the respondent agrees (s.33A(3)), so the judge cannot swap in terms of their own.

What the judge can do is decline to approve your version. They can then explain what concerns them, ask for more information, or direct a hearing. The choice of how to respond stays with the two of you. A judge sets terms of their own only in a contested case, after one of you applies on Form A and the court decides at a final hearing. That is also why a reply needs care: whatever you send back becomes the agreement the court reads next.

What if one of you will not agree to the changes?

Then a changed draft cannot go back, because a consent order needs terms you both agree (s.33A(3)). You can explain why the original terms are fair, negotiate again, or either of you can ask the court to decide the finances.

To ask the court to decide, you apply for a financial order on Form A. First, though, you must attend a meeting about mediation, unless an exception such as domestic abuse applies (GOV.UK: get the court to decide). The case then moves through a first appointment, a financial dispute resolution appointment and, if you still cannot agree, a final hearing. Our Form A guide explains that route. Our guide to financial settlement after divorce covers what to do if your ex will not sign at all.

Expert Tip

Before either of you writes back, put the judge's note beside your draft order and list each point it raises. Answer them in that order in one reply, and attach each corrected page next to the answer it supports. If the note gives a date for your reply and you cannot meet it, ask the court for more time before that date passes.

Iblal Iqbal, Partner & Family Law Strategist

Can the judge approve our consent order on paper once we reply?

Yes, if your reply answers the point. Section 33A lets the court make the order on the information filed with the application unless it has reason to inquire further, so a complete answer can lead to approval without a hearing. If questions remain, the judge can direct a hearing instead.

Do we need a new signed draft if the judge only asks a question?

No. If an explanation answers the point and the terms stay the same, the draft you both signed still stands. A fresh signed draft is needed only when the terms change, because the court needs the respondent's signed agreement to the terms it approves (FPR r.9.26(1)(a)).

Do we both have to attend if the court lists a hearing?

Only if the court directs it. Under FPR r.9.26(4), neither of you needs to attend a consent order hearing unless the court directs otherwise. If the judge's order asks you to attend, you should both go and be ready to explain the agreement.

Does a pension in the consent order need anything extra?

Yes. An order that includes a pension sharing or pension attachment order must say so in its body and come with an annex for each pension arrangement (FPR r.9.35). For a pension attachment, the court cannot make the order until the scheme has had 21 days to object, or the court has considered its objection (FPR r.9.34).

Is our agreement binding while the judge has questions?

Not as a court order. Your agreed terms only become an order once a judge approves them, and the order then takes effect after the final order. Until approval, neither of you can enforce the terms through the court.

Judge sent your agreement back? Get the reply right first time

Two mistakes are easy to make when you reply to a consent order rejected by the judge. The first is changing the terms in a letter instead of a fresh draft that you both sign. The second is answering only part of what the judge asked, which invites another round of questions or a hearing.

A free initial consultation is a conversation with a specialist, who gives you initial advice tailored to your circumstances. It does not include drafting or reviewing documents. If you can, have the court's note to hand when we speak.

Book a free initial consultation or call 0330 094 5880.

You can also read our guides to the D81 form, the cost of a financial order and the sealed consent order. Or return to the financial consent order guide.

General information about the law in England and Wales, not advice on your circumstances.

Written by

Garry Steedman is a family law consultant at Kabir Family Law, specialising in complex divorce, children and property disputes, including TOLATA claims for unmarried couples and cohabitees. He advises on high‑conflict separations, contested children matters and financial settlements, combining clear, straightforward guidance with practical strategies that help clients move forward with confidence. Garry also supports the wider technical trusts of land issues, reviewing complex case files and helping to advise on robust evidence for court and negotiations.

Related Services

8 of 20 guides — scroll sideways for more

Our videos

Short videos from the Kabir Family Law team, explaining family law in plain English.

View all

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting