The calculation letter arrived, and the parent caring for two children read it twice. The figure looked far too small. The other parent ran a successful business and earned well over the statutory ceiling. So the real question was child maintenance above the CMS cap. Our family law specialists advised the parent the children lived with, and this is an anonymised account of what happened.
We share it with our client’s consent. Names, places, dates and figures have been left out. You can read how we prepare and review these success stories before they are published.
A figure that did not match the children’s lives
Before the separation, the children had their clubs, their music lessons and a home close to their school. Afterwards, the statutory figure covered only part of that. Our client felt uneasy asking for more. They also feared that a dispute would pull the children into the middle of it.
The other parent saw it differently. In their view, they already paid what the system asked, and anything extra was unfair. Both feelings were understandable, and neither settled the legal question.
What the law says about child maintenance above the CMS cap
The statutory scheme ignores any gross weekly income over £3,000. That rule is in paragraph 10(3) of Schedule 1 to the Child Support Act 1991. In practice, income above £156,000 a year does not change the figure at all.
Normally a court cannot make its own child maintenance order where the scheme has jurisdiction. Section 8(3) of the same Act says so, and our guide to the CMS or a court order explains that general rule. However, section 8(6) of the Child Support Act 1991 sets out an exception with three conditions. First, a calculation must already be in force. Second, the paying parent’s gross weekly income must exceed the ceiling. Third, the court must be satisfied that extra payments are appropriate in the circumstances.
In this case our client applied under Schedule 1 to the Children Act 1989, on our advice. Married parents can raise the same point within a financial claim on divorce. Under Schedule 1, the court weighs each parent’s income and resources, along with the child’s own needs. It also considers how the child was being, or was expected to be, educated. Paragraph 4(1) of that Schedule lists these factors.
How our family law specialists guided the case
First, we checked that each condition was really met. A calculation was already in force, so a court application would not be premature. Next, we looked closely at the other parent’s income. Salary was only one part of the picture, because dividends and bonuses counted too. Our guide to child maintenance for company directors explains why that matters.
Then we helped our client build a careful budget for the children. Every item came with evidence, from activity costs to travel between the two homes. A high income alone does not justify an order, so we kept the focus on what these particular children needed.
Our client attended a mediation information and assessment meeting before applying, as the law requires unless an exemption applies. After that, our client applied to the court. We advised filing the evidence early and helped prepare it. As a result, the other parent had a clear picture of the case they would have to meet.
The outcome
Once the evidence was in, the discussion moved from principle to numbers. The parents reached an agreement before any final hearing. The court then approved a consent order for periodical payments on top of the statutory calculation. Meanwhile, the calculation itself stayed in place, so the two now work side by side.
For our client, the relief was practical. There was no longer a monthly argument about each school trip or club fee. The children kept the routines they knew.
Every case turns on its own evidence. Nothing here predicts how another family’s case would end.
What to take from this case on child maintenance for high earners
If the other parent earns well over the ceiling, the statutory figure may not be the final word. Get the calculation in place first, because the court cannot add to something that does not exist. Then gather evidence of what your child’s life really costs.
School fees and costs linked to a disability have their own routes under sections 8(7) and 8(8) of the 1991 Act. Neither of those depends on the income ceiling. Our guide to top-up child maintenance orders sets out the wider picture.
If you are the paying parent, the same rules help you too. Clear evidence shows whether a claim for more is fair, and where it goes too far. These questions often sit alongside a wider divorce financial settlement, and the two are best planned together.
“Ask for the order to say what the extra payments cover and how they change as the children grow, such as when sixth form begins. Apply within six months of the calculation and payments can start up to six months before your application, though not before the calculation took effect. A first order ends by the 17th birthday unless the court thinks a later date right, and runs past 18 only for education, training or special circumstances.”
Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law
Talk it through with us
Perhaps you are looking at a calculation that stops short, or at a letter asking you to pay more. Either way, a free initial consultation is a good place to start. You tell one of our child maintenance lawyers what has happened, in confidence. They will explain plainly where you stand on child maintenance above the CMS cap. There is no pressure and no obligation to go further.
When you are ready, call 0330 094 5880 and ask for a free initial consultation.
The legal issue
Two children lived with one parent after the separation. A child maintenance calculation was already in force, but the other parent's gross income was well over the statutory ceiling, so the calculation stopped rising long before it reached the children's real costs.
The parent the children lived with felt the figure no longer matched the children's lives. The other parent felt they already paid what the system required.
The question was whether the court should order periodical payments on top of the statutory calculation, and if so on what evidence.
The law this rests on
- Child Support Act 1991 s.8(1) and s.8(3) - where the statutory scheme has jurisdiction, a court may not make, vary or revive a maintenance order, except as the section allows.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.8(6) - the court may make an order in addition to a maintenance calculation where (a) a calculation is in force, (b) the paying parent's gross weekly income exceeds the Schedule 1 paragraph 10(3) figure, and (c) the circumstances make extra payments appropriate.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.8(7) and s.8(8) - separate routes for the expenses of education or training, and for expenses linked to a child's disability.
- Child Support Act 1991 Schedule 1, paragraph 10(3) - gross weekly income over £3,000 is ignored.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.8(11) - a top-up order can be made under Schedule 1 to the Children Act 1989 or, between spouses, Part II of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973.
- Children Act 1989 s.15 and Schedule 1, paragraph 1(2) - the court's power to order periodical payments for a child.
- Children Act 1989 Schedule 1, paragraph 4(1) - the matters the court must consider, including each parent's resources and the child's needs.
- Children and Families Act 2014 s.10 - attendance at a mediation information and assessment meeting before applying, unless an exemption in the Family Procedure Rules applies.
How we approached it
We started with the statutory conditions. Child Support Act 1991 s.8(6) only opens the door to a court order where a calculation is already in force and the paying parent's income exceeds the ceiling. We checked both before our client applied.
Next we looked at the other parent's true income. Salary was only part of it, and dividends and bonuses had to be brought into view.
Then we helped our client build an evidenced budget for the children, item by item, because s.8(6)(c) asks whether extra payments are appropriate in this family's circumstances. A high income alone does not decide that.
Our client attended a mediation information and assessment meeting, then applied to the court. We advised filing the evidence early and helped prepare it, so the other parent could see the case they had to meet.
The outcome
The parents reached an agreement before a final hearing. The court approved a consent order for periodical payments under Children Act 1989 Schedule 1, on top of the statutory calculation, which stayed in place.
Outcomes of this kind turn entirely on the evidence about the individual children's needs and the individual parent's resources. Nothing here is a prediction or a promise about any other case.
What to take from this
- The statutory calculation ignores gross weekly income over £3,000 (Child Support Act 1991 Schedule 1 paragraph 10(3)), so it stops rising at about £156,000 a year.
- Get the calculation in place first. Child Support Act 1991 s.8(6)(a) requires one to be in force before the court can add to it.
- A high income is not enough on its own. The court must be satisfied that extra payments are appropriate, so evidence of the child's real costs is what counts.
- School fees and disability costs have their own routes under Child Support Act 1991 s.8(7) and s.8(8), and neither depends on the income ceiling.
- Look at the whole income. Dividends and bonuses can matter as much as salary.
Checked and approved for publication by Hannah Overton.
Last reviewed .