Success story
Published 11 mins read12 sections

Her husband was a couple of years from retirement. When his pension paid out, he would receive a lump sum and an income. She needed part of that lump sum the day it arrived, to clear the last of her mortgage. Our family law specialists explained why a pension attachment order, rather than a pension share, suited her case. This is an anonymised account.

A pension close to payment and a mortgage to clear

The marriage had been long. He had a defined benefit pension from most of his working life, and hers was smaller. She was keeping the family home, but the last of the mortgage fell due around when he would retire. Her income could not clear it, and she feared she would have to sell.

His first proposal offered a share of that pension, plus an attachment of part of its lump sum. Yet a share would become a pension in her own name. She could not draw on it until years after he retired.

What the law says about a pension attachment order

Under section 25B of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, the court must have regard to pension benefits. Section 25B(4) lets the order require the scheme to pay the other spouse part of any payment due to the member. This is a pension attachment order, often called earmarking.

Under section 25B(5), the amount must be a percentage of the payment that becomes due. Section 25B(7) deals with commutation, which means swapping pension for a lump sum. Where the member has that right, the order may require him to exercise it to any extent.

Section 25C covers a lump sum payable on the member’s death. The court can order all or part of it to be paid to the other spouse, or require the member to nominate them.

However, the Act keeps sharing and attachment apart for the same pension. Section 24B(5) bars a pension sharing order where an attachment requirement on that pension is in force. In turn, sections 25B(7B) and 25C(4) bar attachment where a pension sharing order in the marriage covers that pension.

The risks of pension attachment

We warned her that an attachment only takes effect when a payment becomes due to him. He would largely control the timing. If he died before retiring, there would be no retirement lump sum to share.

Attached income is weaker still, because it is paid under a periodical payments order. Section 28(1)(a) says such an order cannot extend beyond the death of either spouse. An order made on or after the divorce order also ends on the receiving spouse’s remarriage or new civil partnership. A pension share avoids these limits.

What our family law specialists advised

First, we advised her that a share and an attachment cannot sit on the same pension, so she had to choose one. Next, we helped her get the scheme’s figures for both lump sums. With them, she could fix the percentage that would clear the mortgage, with a margin for change.

We then advised her on the terms to ask for. Under section 25B(7), the order could require him to take the largest lump sum the scheme offered. He could not then shrink it by taking more income. Under section 25C, it could also direct part of any lump sum payable on his death to her. Finally, we suggested she ask him to agree to draw his benefits at the scheme’s normal retirement date.

Her own pension and earnings covered her income needs. So we advised against attaching his pension income, which would stop if she remarried.

How the attachment order was approved

The couple agreed terms, and she applied for a consent order with our guidance. Rule 9.34 of the Family Procedure Rules 2010 required the parties to serve the scheme with the application, the proposed order and her address and payment details. She did this with our help. The court could not make the order until 21 days from service passed with no objection, or until it had considered any objection.

Rule 9.35 requires the order to say there is provision by way of pension attachment, set out in an annex. We helped her complete that annex on Form P2. The scheme raised no objection, and the court approved the order.

When he retired, the scheme paid her share of the lump sum straight to her, and she cleared the mortgage. Every case turns on its own facts, so this is not a promise about any other family.

What you can take from this

A pension share is usually the safer choice, because it gives you a pension of your own. A pension attachment order can fit when you need money at the moment their pension pays out. If you choose it, ask for terms that make them take the lump sum and protect you if they die first.

Our pension sharing order guide explains the other route. See also our pension CETV and financial consent order guides, and how we prepare these success stories.

“An attachment order can sit quietly for years before anything is paid, so keep the paperwork current. If your address or bank details change, tell the scheme in writing within 14 days, because a scheme that cannot reach you may pay the member instead and owe you nothing for that payment. If the whole pension moves to a new scheme, the old scheme must send the new one the order and tell you, so check your details went too.”

Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law

Talk it through with us

If you are weighing a pension share against a pension attachment order, you do not need to decide alone. A free initial consultation is confidential and carries no obligation. Bring your latest pension statement and any proposal. Our family law specialists will explain your options before you agree anything.

The legal issue

A long marriage was ending. The husband had a defined benefit pension and was a couple of years from the scheme's retirement date, when it would pay him a lump sum and an income. The wife was keeping the family home, but the last part of the mortgage fell due at about the same time, and her income could not clear it. His first proposal offered a pension share plus an attachment of part of his lump sum from the same scheme. A share would have become a pension in her own name that she could not draw on until some years after his retirement.

The law this rests on

  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25B(4): the order may require the person responsible for the pension arrangement, if any payment in respect of benefits under it becomes due to the party with pension rights, to make a payment for the benefit of the other party.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25B(5): the order must express the amount of any such payment as a percentage of the payment which becomes due to the party with pension rights.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25B(7): where the party with pension rights has a right of commutation under the arrangement, the order may require him to exercise it to any extent.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25C(1) and (2): where the pension benefits include a lump sum payable on the member's death, the court may require the person responsible to pay the whole or part of it to the other party, or require the member to nominate the other party, depending on who has the power to decide.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.24B(5): a pension sharing order may not be made in relation to a person's rights under a pension arrangement if a requirement imposed by virtue of s.25B or s.25C, relating to benefits under that arrangement, is in force.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25B(7B) and s.25C(4): the attachment powers may not be exercised in relation to a pension arrangement which is the subject of a pension sharing order in relation to the marriage, or has been the subject of pension sharing between the parties to the marriage.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.28(1)(a): a periodical payments order cannot extend beyond the death of either party or, where it is made on or after the making of a divorce or nullity of marriage order, the remarriage of, or formation of a civil partnership by, the party in whose favour it is made.
  • Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.9.34: where the parties have agreed terms that include a pension attachment order, they must serve on the person responsible for the pension arrangement a copy of the application for a consent order, the proposed order and the particulars in r.9.33(1) (an address for notices, an address for payments and account details). No such consent order is made unless there is no objection within 21 days of service or the court has considered any objection.
  • Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.9.35: the order must state that there is provision by way of pension attachment in accordance with the annex, and must be accompanied by a pension attachment annex for each pension arrangement.
  • Form P2 (Pension attachment annex under section 25B or 25C of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973), published on GOV.UK.

How we approached it

We explained the difference between pension sharing and pension attachment, and the risks of attachment: it depends on him taking his benefits, there is no retirement lump sum if he dies first, and attached income ends on the death of either spouse or her remarriage. We advised her that the Act does not allow a share and an attachment on the same pension, so she should choose one route for that scheme. We helped her get the scheme's figures and work out the percentage of the lump sum needed to clear the mortgage, because section 25B(5) requires a percentage. We advised her to ask that the order require him to take the largest lump sum the scheme allowed (s.25B(7)) and direct part of any lump sum payable on his death to her (s.25C). We also suggested she ask him to agree, as part of the terms, to draw his benefits at the scheme's normal retirement date. Her own pension and earnings met her income needs, so we advised against attaching his pension income. She applied for a consent order with our guidance. Rule 9.34 requires the parties to serve the scheme, and she did so with our help. We also helped her complete the Form P2 annex.

The outcome

The couple agreed terms. With our guidance, she applied for a consent order and served the scheme with the papers that rule 9.34 requires the parties to serve. The scheme raised no objection, and the court approved the order with a Form P2 pension attachment annex. When the husband retired, the scheme paid her agreed percentage of his lump sum straight to her, and she cleared the mortgage and kept her home. Every case turns on its own facts, and this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from this

  • A pension share is usually the safer route. It gives you a pension of your own that does not depend on your former spouse.
  • A pension attachment order can fit when you need money at the point their pension pays out, such as a lump sum to clear a mortgage.
  • Attachment depends on the member taking benefits. Attached income is paid under a periodical payments order, which ends on the death of either spouse and, if made on or after the divorce order, on the remarriage or new civil partnership of the one receiving it (s.28(1)(a)).
  • The order must express the payment as a percentage (s.25B(5)). It can require the member to commute part of the pension to a lump sum (s.25B(7)) and can direct a lump sum payable on death to you (s.25C).
  • A share and an attachment cannot be put on the same pension in the same marriage (s.24B(5), s.25B(7B), s.25C(4)).
  • If agreed terms include attachment, the parties must serve the scheme. The consent order cannot be made until 21 days pass without objection, or the court has considered any objection (FPR r.9.34).

Checked and approved for publication by Hannah Overton.

Last reviewed .

Read more about this area of family law

Pension Sharing Order

Author:

Garry Steedman is a family law consultant at Kabir Family Law, specialising in complex divorce, children and property disputes, including TOLATA claims for unmarried couples and cohabitees. He advises on high‑conflict separations, contested children matters and financial settlements, combining clear, straightforward guidance with practical strategies that help clients move forward with confidence. Garry also supports the wider technical trusts of land issues, reviewing complex case files and helping to advise on robust evidence for court and negotiations.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting