Family law guide

Published Last reviewed 14 mins read 10 sections

Part of: Interim and Final Care Orders: What Happens and How to Protect Your Position

Long-term foster care versus adoption is a choice between two very different legal homes for a child who cannot go back to their parents. In long-term foster care, the child usually stays in the council’s care under a care order until 18, and the birth parents keep parental responsibility. Adoption, by contrast, makes the adopters the child’s parents for life and ends the birth parents’ legal tie.

Both plans can give a child a settled home with the same carers. However, they differ on who makes decisions, how contact works and what happens at 18. This guide explains those differences, how the court chooses between the plans and whether long-term foster carers can adopt. It is part of our guide to adopting a child and covers the law in England and Wales.

Key takeaways

  • Parental responsibility is the dividing line. Under a care order the council shares it with the parents (Children Act 1989, s.33(3)). An adoption order ends the parents’ share for good (Adoption and Children Act 2002, s.46(2)).
  • Long-term fostering has a legal meaning. The child’s plan for permanence is foster care, the carer agrees to look after the child until they leave care, and the council confirms the arrangement.
  • Adoption without consent is a last resort. Courts make such orders only where “nothing else will do” (Re B-S, para 22).
  • Foster carers can apply to adopt. Usually the child must first have lived with them for a year (ACA 2002, s.42(4)).
  • The routes part at 18. A care order ends at 18, while an adopted child stays the adopters’ child for life.

Facing a care plan of long-term fostering or adoption? You can book a free initial consultation to talk it through with one of our specialists before the final hearing.

What is the difference between long-term foster care and adoption?

The difference is parental responsibility. In long-term foster care, the council and the birth parents both hold it while the foster carers look after the child day to day, whereas after adoption only the adopters hold it.

A care order gives the council parental responsibility alongside the parents. The council can also limit how far the parents use theirs, but only where that is necessary to safeguard or promote the child’s welfare (Children Act 1989, s.33(3) and (4)). So a parent of a child in long-term foster care is still a parent in law. They usually keep a right to reasonable contact, and they can ask the court to end the care order.

An adoption order works very differently. It gives parental responsibility to the adopters and extinguishes everyone else’s (Adoption and Children Act 2002, s.46). It also brings any care order to an end. From then on, the child is treated in law as if born to the adopters (s.67(1)). That is why the difference between fostering and adoption weighs so heavily on birth families. One plan keeps them in the child’s legal life, while the other ends that tie.

What counts as long-term fostering?

Long-term fostering is a defined arrangement, so the label alone does not create one. The care planning regulations treat a placement as long term only when three conditions are met (Care Planning, Placement and Case Review (England) Regulations 2010, reg 2(1)):

  • the child’s plan for permanence is foster care;
  • the foster carer has agreed to look after the child until the child stops being looked after; and
  • the council has confirmed the arrangement to the carer, the child’s parents and the child.

If nobody has confirmed the placement as long term, it may still be temporary, whatever people call it. For that reason, ask the social worker to confirm the position in writing.

Most long-term placements follow a care order. A council can also look after a child with the parents’ agreement under section 20, and then anyone with parental responsibility can usually remove the child at any time (Children Act 1989, s.20(8)). Our guide to section 20 accommodation explains that route.

Long-term foster care versus adoption: what changes in law

Almost every legal question a family asks has a different answer under each plan, from who holds parental responsibility to what happens at 18.

Long-term foster care and adoption compared
QuestionLong-term foster careAdoption
Who holds parental responsibility?The council and the birth parents (CA 1989, s.33(3))The adopters only (ACA 2002, s.46)
Contact with parentsReasonable contact unless a court orders otherwise (CA 1989, s.34)What the adopters agree, or a court orders (ACA 2002, s.51A)
A new surnameNeeds the written consent of everyone with parental responsibility, or the court’s leave (CA 1989, s.33(7))The adopters decide
Can parents apply to end it?Yes, by applying to discharge the care order (CA 1989, s.39)No, because their parental responsibility has ended (ACA 2002, s.46(2))
When does it end?When the child turns 18 (CA 1989, s.91(12))It does not: the child is the adopters’ child for life (ACA 2002, s.67)

In practice, long-term fostering keeps the council involved. The child has a social worker and regular reviews, and in England every foster carer gets a foster care allowance towards the cost of caring for the child (GOV.UK). Adoption takes the council out of daily decisions once the order is made. Even so, adoptive families can still get help: the adoption and special guardianship support fund pays for therapy, and the council or regional adoption agency applies for it.

How does the court choose between long-term fostering and adoption?

The court chooses the plan that meets the child’s welfare throughout their life, and it treats adoption without parental consent as a last resort. In Re B-S (Children) [2013] EWCA Civ 1146, the Court of Appeal restated the Supreme Court’s test: such orders are made only where “nothing else will do” (para 22).

When the choice is long-term foster care versus adoption, the evidence must address both plans and every other realistic option, with the arguments for and against each one (para 34). The court therefore weighs the two plans against each other, along with any placement with family. The Court of Appeal called this a “global, holistic” evaluation (para 44). As a result, an option should not be chosen just because the others were knocked out one at a time.

For any adoption decision, the child’s welfare throughout their life is the paramount consideration (Adoption and Children Act 2002, s.1(2)). The court must also weigh the checklist in section 1(4). That list includes the likely effect on the child, for life, of ceasing to be a member of their birth family. It also asks about the child’s relationships with relatives and whether those relationships could continue. Finally, the court must not make an order unless doing so would be better for the child than making none (s.1(6)).

Consent is the other hurdle. The court can only dispense with a parent’s consent if the parent cannot be found or lacks capacity, or if the child’s welfare requires it (s.52(1)). Our guide to placement orders explains how that step usually comes first.

Long-term foster care vs adoption: two carers sit in the garden outside their home with a smiling child between them
Either plan can give a child the same carers. What changes is who the law treats as that child’s parents.

Long-term foster care vs adoption: what each plan means for you

How much the difference between fostering and adoption matters to you depends on your role and the stage of the case. Answer three questions to see your legal position, what you can still ask for and the decision to weigh with a specialist.

1. Who are you to the child?
2. What is the plan right now?
3. What matters most to you?
0 of 3 answered

Where your answers lead

Answer the three questions to fill in each line. Nothing you choose leaves this page.

  1. What this plan means in lawWho holds parental responsibility under the plan, and how long it lasts.
  2. Your positionWhat the law lets someone in your role ask for at this stage of the case.
  3. What protects what matters to youThe part of the plan to focus on, given what matters most to you.
The judgement callThe decision no checker can make for you, and the one to weigh with a specialist.

Book a free initial consultation

Can foster carers adopt the child they look after?

Yes. Local authority foster carers can apply to adopt once the child has lived with them for one year before the application (Adoption and Children Act 2002, s.42(4)). The court can also give them leave to apply sooner (s.42(6)).

Unless the council places the child with them for adoption, the carers must also give the council notice of their intention to adopt. That notice must come at least three months, and no more than two years, before the application (s.44(3)). The council then investigates and reports to the court. The usual consent rules still apply, so the parents’ consent is needed unless the court dispenses with it.

Some carers choose special guardianship instead. A foster carer can apply for a special guardianship order once the child has lived with them for a year, after giving the council three months’ notice (Children Act 1989, s.14A(5)(d) and (7)). The order brings the care order to an end (s.91(5A)). The birth parents keep parental responsibility, although the special guardian can generally exercise it without them (s.14C(1)).

Our guide to special guardianship orders explains that route. Where carers plan from the start to foster and then adopt, our foster to adopt guide applies. For step-families, our comparison of step-parent adoption and special guardianship covers a different choice.

How does contact with the birth family work under each plan?

In long-term foster care, the council must allow the child reasonable contact with their parents (Children Act 1989, s.34(1)). After adoption, contact depends on what the adopters agree or what a court orders.

A council can refuse contact without a court order only in an emergency. The refusal must be necessary for the child’s welfare, and it cannot last more than seven days (s.34(6)). Parents can ask the court to set contact. Other relatives need the court’s leave to apply first (s.34(3)). The exception is a relative the child lived with under a child arrangements order just before the care order (s.34(1)(c)). Once section 10 of the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 comes into force, the council’s duty of reasonable contact will also cover the child’s brothers and sisters.

Adoption changes that position. Before it makes an adoption order, the court must consider whether there should be contact arrangements (ACA 2002, s.46(6)). After the order, birth relatives need the court’s leave just to apply for a contact order (s.51A(4)(c)). Our guide to post adoption contact explains letterbox contact and those applications.

What changes at 18 under each plan?

A care order ends when the child turns 18 (Children Act 1989, s.91(12)), so long-term foster care ends in law at that point. Adoption has no end date, because an adopted person is treated as the adopters’ child for life (ACA 2002, s.67(1)).

Young people leaving long-term foster care still have support, though. If they want to keep living with their former foster carers, the council must support a staying put arrangement until they turn 21. That support must include money for the carers (s.23CZA). The council must also give care leavers a personal adviser, usually until 21 and up to their 25th birthday if they ask. Our guide for care leavers sets out that support in full.

We advised a mother whose son had lived with the same foster carers since he was a toddler. The council’s plan had shifted from long-term fostering towards adoption by those carers, and she assumed objecting was her only choice. We explained that the carers could ask the court for special guardianship instead, which would leave her parental responsibility in place. She went into the final hearing able to argue for an option the court had to weigh alongside adoption, backed by evidence of the contact she had kept up.

Expert Tip

Ask the social worker which options the council assessed, and why each one was ruled out. The court has to weigh every realistic option, so a relative or a long-term foster placement that nobody assessed is a gap worth raising. Raise it while the evidence is still being prepared, because by the final hearing there is little time left for new assessments.

Hannah Overton, Complex Children Specialist & Client Support

Long-term foster care vs adoption: frequently asked questions

Can I get my child back from long-term foster care?

Possibly. As a parent with parental responsibility, you can apply to the court to discharge the care order (Children Act 1989, s.39(1)). You will need to show that things have changed and that a return home now serves your child’s welfare. Our guide to discharging a care order explains what the court looks for.

Can a long-term foster placement end before 18?

Yes. The placement rests on the carer’s agreement and the council’s care plan, and no court order names the carer. If the placement breaks down, the child stays in care and moves to another placement. An adopted child has no such fallback, because the adopters are the child’s parents in law.

Do adopters get the same support as foster carers?

Not in the same way. In England, every foster carer gets a foster care allowance, while adopters get financial support from the council only in set cases, such as a child who needs extra care because of disability or past neglect (Adoption Support Services Regulations 2005, reg 8). Foster carers who adopt may keep a fee element, usually for up to two years, if the council decides before the adoption order that it is needed (reg 9). The adoption and special guardianship support fund can also pay for therapy.

Can a child in long-term foster care change their surname?

Only with consent or the court’s permission. While a care order is in force, no one may give the child a new surname without the written consent of everyone with parental responsibility, or the court’s leave (Children Act 1989, s.33(7)). The same rule covers taking the child out of the United Kingdom, apart from trips of less than a month arranged by the council.

Does adoption end all contact with the birth family?

Not always. In law, an adopted child is no longer the child of their birth parents (ACA 2002, s.67(3)). Contact can still continue by agreement or court order, and the court must consider contact arrangements before it makes an adoption order (s.46(6)).

Care plan pointing to adoption or long-term fostering?

In long-term foster care vs adoption cases, the mistake that costs families most is waiting. A relative who comes forward late, or an argument for long-term foster care raised for the first time at the final hearing, may never be fully assessed. The court has to weigh every realistic option, so put yours forward while the evidence is still being gathered. Once an adoption order is made, the birth parents have no route to apply to discharge it.

A free initial consultation is a conversation with a specialist, who gives you initial advice tailored to your circumstances. It does not include drafting or reviewing documents. If you can, have the latest care plan to hand when we speak.

Book a free initial consultation or call 0330 094 5880.

You can also read our guides to placement orders, adoption orders and interim and final care orders. Or return to adopting a child.

General information about the law in England and Wales, not advice on your circumstances.

Written by

Hannah Overton is a complex children specialist at Kabir Family Law, focusing on child arrangements disputes, fact‑finding hearings and cases involving CAFCASS and safeguarding concerns in the family courts of England and Wales. She has extensive experience supporting parents through allegation‑heavy proceedings and creates clear, practical resources that explain court processes, evidence preparation and contact arrangements. Hannah also works closely with the client services team to ensure families receive informed, compassionate guidance at every stage of their case.

Related Services

8 of 41 guides — scroll sideways for more

Our videos

Short videos from the Kabir Family Law team, explaining family law in plain English.

View all

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting