Three months after her financial order was sealed, a mother watched the plan behind it fall apart. Her children had moved into her one-bedroom flat, while the family home stayed with their father. Our family law specialists advised her on whether this was a Barder event, and how to ask the court to look again. This account is anonymised.
An order built on one plan
After a long marriage, the couple agreed their two children would live mainly with their father in the family home, near their schools. Her shift work made that practical. He kept the house and mortgage. She took a smaller lump sum and a clean break, and rented a flat.
The terms went into a financial consent order, which the court approved. A recital recorded the basis: the children would live with their father in that home. That line became the centre of her case.
Weeks later, his employer announced it was closing his office, and he took a post abroad. The children would not leave their schools, so they moved in with her. Then the house went on the market. She slept on the sofa so they could share the bedroom. Having signed a clean break, she believed she was stuck.
What is a Barder event?
The phrase comes from a House of Lords case. It means an event after a financial order that nobody foresaw or could have foreseen, and that knocks away the basis the order rested on. Under rule 9.9A of the Family Procedure Rules 2010, a party can apply to set aside all or part of a financial remedy order, including a consent order, where nobody alleges an error by the court. Practice Direction 9A lists such an event as one ground.
The House of Lords set four strict conditions. First, the event must invalidate the basis, or fundamental assumption, of the order. Second, it should come within a relatively short time: usually a few months, and extremely unlikely to be as much as a year. Third, the application must be made reasonably quickly in the circumstances. Fourth, reopening the order must not harm anyone who has since bought an interest in the property in good faith.
Successful applications are rare, because the courts give real weight to finality. A change of heart will not do. The court also starts from the view that the order was properly made, so the ground must be proved or admitted.
How we tested the Barder event, and why speed mattered
We tested her case against each condition. The recital showed the agreed basis, and the move came within three months. We also checked whether the father had known about the closure before he signed, since material non-disclosure would then have been the better ground. However, the employer’s announcement came weeks after the order, and his messages showed a genuine surprise.
The house was for sale, so speed mattered: a sale to a buyer could defeat the fourth condition. We helped her write to him that week, asking him not to exchange contracts until the court had decided. He agreed in writing. We also advised her to apply within weeks, so nobody could say she had delayed.
For evidence, we helped her gather the order, school and GP records showing the children’s new address, the employer’s announcement, his messages, her tenancy and local rents.
Finally, we explained the procedure. An appeal is for an error by the court, and nobody said the judge had erred. The right route was therefore rule 9.9A, applying within the original financial proceedings to the court that made the order. We advised her to ask the court to set aside only the parts about the home and the clean break. She applied with our guidance, and we helped her prepare a statement taking the judge through each condition.
The outcome
The father accepted that the closure had surprised him too. The judge found a Barder event and set aside the parts of the order about the home and the clean break. The rest stood, and the court gave directions for a fresh decision on those issues.
When it decides again, the court applies section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, giving first consideration to the children’s welfare while they are minors. The parents then agreed a new consent order. They would sell the house and she would receive a much larger share, enough for a modest home near the schools. Every case turns on its own facts, so this is no promise for anyone else.
If you think you have a Barder event
Move quickly. The test speaks of months, and delay can count against you. If the other person is selling an asset the order covers, ask them in writing to hold off.
Check your order’s recitals, because a short recital can prove what everyone assumed. Our guides to a financial settlement after divorce and what happens after a sealed consent order explain the wider process. You can also read how we prepare these success stories.
“Ask yourself two things before you apply. Could anyone have foreseen this change when the order was made? And did the other person know and keep quiet? Those are different grounds for setting an order aside, each needing its own evidence, so build on the one your papers prove. Setting aside only reopens the order. The court then hears those issues again, with your children’s welfare its first consideration, so prepare figures for your housing and income.”
Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law
Talk it through with us
If something has changed since your financial order and you fear you are stuck with it, talk to us soon. A free initial consultation is confidential, with no obligation. Our family law specialists will tell you honestly whether you may have a case. Use the form below to book it.
The legal issue
A divorcing couple agreed a financial consent order on the basis that their two children would live mainly with their father in the family home. He kept the house and its mortgage. She took a smaller lump sum, agreed a clean break and rented a small flat. The order recorded that basis in a recital. A few weeks after the order was sealed, his employer announced the closure of his office and he accepted a post abroad. The children moved in with their mother, and the house went on the market. She believed she was stuck with a final order that no longer made sense.
The law this rests on
- Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.9.9A(1)(a) and (2): a party may apply to set aside a financial remedy order, or part of one, including a consent order, where no error of the court is alleged.
- Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.9.9A(3) and (4): the application is made within the proceedings in which the order was made, using the Part 18 procedure.
- Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.9.9A(5): if the court sets the order aside, it gives directions for a rehearing or makes other orders to dispose of the application.
- Practice Direction 9A paras 13.3 and 13.4: for an order made on or after 22 April 2014, the application goes to the court that made the order and is dealt with by the same level of judge, where reasonably possible the same judge.
- Practice Direction 9A para 13.5: the grounds include fraud, material non-disclosure, certain limited types of mistake, and a later event, unforeseen and unforeseeable when the order was made, which invalidates its basis. Where an error of the court is alleged, an appeal is the route to consider.
- Practice Direction 9A para 13.8: the starting point is that the order was properly made, and the ground must be established, or admitted, before the court can set it aside.
- Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984 s.31F(6): the family court may vary, suspend, rescind or revive any order it has made.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(1) and (2): in deciding financial orders, the court has regard to all the circumstances, first consideration being given to the welfare while a minor of any child of the family, and to factors including each party's needs, obligations and responsibilities.
- The four conditions set by the House of Lords in the case that gave the Barder event its name: the new event invalidates the basis or fundamental assumption of the order; it happens within a relatively short time, in most cases no more than a few months and extremely unlikely to be as much as a year; the application is made reasonably quickly in the circumstances of the case; and reopening the order does not prejudice third parties who have acquired an interest in the property in good faith and for value.
How we approached it
We tested her case against each of the four conditions for a Barder event. The recital showed the agreed basis, and the move came within three months. We checked whether the father had known about the closure before he signed, because that would have made material non-disclosure the better ground. The employer's public announcement and his messages showed it was a genuine surprise.
Because the house was for sale, and a sale to a buyer in good faith could defeat the fourth condition, we helped her write to him that week asking him not to exchange contracts until the court had decided. He agreed in writing. We advised her to apply within a few weeks.
We helped her gather the order, school and GP records showing the children's new address, the employer's announcement, his messages, her tenancy, her income and local rental costs. We explained that an appeal is for an error by the court, so the right route was an application under Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.9.9A within the original proceedings, to the court that made the order. We advised her to ask the court to set aside only the parts dealing with the home and the clean break. She applied with our guidance, and we helped her prepare a statement taking the judge through each condition.
The outcome
The father accepted that the closure had surprised him too. The judge found the conditions met and set aside the parts of the order dealing with the family home and the clean break, leaving the rest in place, and gave directions for those issues to be decided again. With the children's welfare as the first consideration under Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25, the parents negotiated a new consent order: the house would be sold and she would receive a much larger share, enough to buy a modest home near the children's schools. Every case turns on its own facts, and this is not a promise about any other family.
What to take from this
- Successful Barder event applications are rare. A change of heart, or a change you could have seen coming, will not do.
- Act within weeks. The new event should come within a few months of the order, and the application must be made reasonably quickly.
- Protect the asset. If the other person is selling property covered by the order, ask them in writing not to exchange contracts until the court has decided.
- Read your order's recitals. A recorded basis for the agreement can prove what everyone assumed.
- Choose the right route. Where no error of the court is alleged, the application is made under Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.9.9A within the original proceedings; an appeal is for an error by the court.
- You can ask the court to set aside only the part of the order that the event has undermined.
Checked and approved for publication by Hannah Overton.
Last reviewed .