Success story
Published 10 mins read12 sections

Each month she checked her bank account to see whether the payment had arrived. Years after the divorce, she still relied on joint lives maintenance from a former husband who wanted out. When he asked the court to end it, our family law specialists advised her on another answer: one lump sum, worked out on a Duxbury basis, and a clean break. This is an anonymised account.

Maintenance from an ex who wanted out

After a long marriage, she had given up her career to bring up their children, while he built his. On divorce, he agreed to pay her monthly maintenance for joint lives. She found part time work, but her pay could not cover the bills on its own.

Over the years, some payments arrived late. Then his messages started to mention retirement. Finally, he applied to the court to bring the maintenance to an end after a short period.

She feared being left with nothing at a stage of life when a full time job would be hard to find. If your ex has started talking about retirement, you may know that fear.

What the law says about ending spousal maintenance

When a court makes financial orders on or after a divorce, section 25A of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 gives it a duty to consider whether each spouse’s financial obligations to the other should end as soon after the divorce as it considers just and reasonable. For this couple, the answer had instead been a joint lives order for spousal maintenance. Under section 28(1)(a), such payments cannot run beyond the death of either of them, or her remarriage or new civil partnership.

Even so, the order could change. Under section 31 of the Act, the court has power to vary or discharge a periodical payments order. It looks at all the circumstances, including any change in the matters it weighed when making the order. It is also under a duty to consider whether it would be appropriate to limit payments to a further period, long enough for her to adjust without undue hardship to their end. That was his case.

However, section 31(7B) offers another route. When the court ends maintenance after a divorce, or limits it to a further period, it can also make a lump sum order for the person receiving it. It can add a direction that she may not apply for maintenance again. Lawyers call this capitalising maintenance, and with that direction the result is a clean break order.

How a Duxbury calculation works

That lump sum is often worked out on a Duxbury basis. A Duxbury calculation uses set assumptions about the economy and tax. From those, it finds the lump sum that, if invested suitably, would give her enough income to meet her needs for the rest of her life. As a result, her expected lifespan is part of the sum, and so is the gap between her needs and her other income.

What our family law specialists advised

First, we advised her to see his application as an opening. He wanted an end, and she wanted certainty. A capitalised lump sum could give them both.

Next, we helped her build a careful budget of her yearly needs, from housing and bills to replacing a car. We also helped her set out her pay and the pension she expected later, so the Duxbury figure would match the true gap.

Then we advised her to ask for his full and up to date financial disclosure, to show that a lump sum was affordable. On our advice, she also asked an independent financial adviser whether the fund would last with cautious investment.

Timing mattered too. A bar on any future claim was what he wanted most. For that reason, we advised her to agree to it only once the lump sum was settled, with maintenance running until the money reached her account. With our guidance, she put forward a proposal built on the Duxbury figure, and we guided her through each round of negotiation.

A Duxbury lump sum and a clean break

The couple agreed a lump sum close to her Duxbury figure. Under the agreed order, her maintenance ended once he had paid it, and she could not apply for maintenance again. They sent the agreed order to the court, which approved it.

Today she manages the fund with her adviser and no longer waits for a monthly transfer. Every case turns on its own evidence, so this is not a promise about any other family.

What you can take from a Duxbury lump sum

If your former spouse wants to end your maintenance, ask whether it can be capitalised. A lump sum removes the risk of late payments, a cut when they retire, or payments stopping on their death.

Above all, the figure depends on your evidence, so start with a careful budget. Our guide to financial settlement after divorce explains the wider picture. You can also read how we prepare these success stories.

“Settle how the lump sum is paid as carefully as the figure itself. Instalments leave room for late or missed payments, so money your budget depends on is less certain than a single sum. Where instalments cannot be avoided, the order can require them to be secured to the court’s satisfaction, and it is wise to let your maintenance end only once the final instalment has reached you.”

Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law

Talk it through with us

Whether you receive maintenance or pay it, you do not need to work this out alone. A free initial consultation is confidential and carries no obligation. Bring your current order and a note of your monthly costs. Our family law specialists will explain whether a Duxbury lump sum could work for you.

The legal issue

After a long marriage in which she gave up her career to bring up the children, a former wife received monthly spousal maintenance for joint lives. Her part time pay could not cover her bills without it. Years after the divorce, payments sometimes arrived late, her former husband began to talk about retirement, and he then applied to the court to bring the maintenance to an end after a short period. She feared being left with nothing at a stage of life when full time work would be hard to find.

The law this rests on

  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.23(1)(a) and (c): on making a divorce order, or at any time after, the court may order periodical payments for such term as the order specifies, and a lump sum or sums.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(a) and (b): in deciding financial orders for a spouse, the court shall in particular have regard to each party's income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources, and their financial needs, obligations and responsibilities, now and in the foreseeable future. On a variation, s.31(7) brings in any change in those matters.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25A(1): when the court exercises those powers on or after a divorce order, it has a duty to consider whether each party's financial obligations towards the other should end as soon after the order as the court considers just and reasonable.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.28(1)(a): a periodical payments order made on or after a divorce order cannot extend beyond the death of either party, or the remarriage or new civil partnership of the party receiving the payments.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.31(1) and (2)(b): the court has power to vary or discharge a periodical payments order.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.31(7) and (7)(a): the court has regard to all the circumstances, including any change in the matters it considered when making the order, and has a duty to consider whether it would be appropriate to limit payments to a further period sufficient for the recipient to adjust without undue hardship to their end.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.31(7A) and (7B)(a) and (c): where, after a divorce, the court discharges a periodical payments order or limits it to a further period, it may also order a lump sum in favour of a party to the marriage, and direct that the party who received the payments may not apply again for periodical payments or for an extension of the term.
  • Law Commission, Matrimonial Property, Needs and Agreements (Law Com No 343, 2014): a Duxbury calculation uses certain economic and fiscal assumptions to produce a lump sum which, if suitably invested, would provide sufficient income to meet the recipient spouse's requirements for the rest of their life.

How we approached it

We advised her to see his application as an opening: he wanted out, and she wanted certainty, so a lump sum in place of maintenance could meet both aims.

We helped her build a careful budget of her yearly needs and set out her pay from work and the pension she expected later, so a Duxbury calculation would measure the true gap. We advised her to ask for his full and up to date financial disclosure, to show a lump sum was affordable, and to ask an independent financial adviser to test whether the fund would last on a cautious approach to investment.

Because a bar on any future maintenance claim was what he wanted most, we advised her to agree to it only once the lump sum was settled, and to keep her maintenance running until the money reached her account. With our guidance, she put forward a proposal built on the Duxbury figure, and we guided her through each round of negotiation.

The outcome

The couple agreed a lump sum close to her Duxbury figure. Under the agreed order, her maintenance ended once he had paid the lump sum, and she could not apply for maintenance again. They sent the agreed order to the court, and the court approved it. She now manages the fund with her financial adviser and no longer depends on a monthly transfer from her former husband. Every case turns on its own evidence, and this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from this

  • If your former spouse applies to end your maintenance, ask whether it can be capitalised into a lump sum under Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.31(7B).
  • A Duxbury calculation turns your yearly income needs into one lump sum meant to last the rest of your life, so the figure depends on your evidence.
  • Build a careful budget and set out your own pay and expected pension: the fund only has to cover the gap.
  • Ask for full financial disclosure, and ask an independent financial adviser to test whether the fund would last.
  • Agree to a bar on future maintenance claims only once the lump sum is settled, and keep maintenance running until the money is paid.

Checked and approved for publication by Hannah Overton.

Last reviewed .

Read more about this area of family law

Spousal Maintenance

Author:

Garry Steedman is a family law consultant at Kabir Family Law, specialising in complex divorce, children and property disputes, including TOLATA claims for unmarried couples and cohabitees. He advises on high‑conflict separations, contested children matters and financial settlements, combining clear, straightforward guidance with practical strategies that help clients move forward with confidence. Garry also supports the wider technical trusts of land issues, reviewing complex case files and helping to advise on robust evidence for court and negotiations.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting