Success story
Published 10 mins read12 sections

A husband was reading an offer from his wife’s lawyers. She had worked as a nurse for most of their long marriage, and her NHS pension was by far the largest thing they owned. The offer would split it so they each kept the same cash equivalent transfer value (CETV), counting his small private pension. It looked fair. Before he replied, our family law specialists advised him on what an NHS pension divorce involves. This is an anonymised account.

A nurse’s pension and a long marriage

She still worked hospital shifts and, over decades, had built up rights in more than one part of the NHS Pension Scheme. He had run a small business and saved little for retirement.

He was uneasy asking for more of something she had earned on nights and weekends. But he had to live on whatever pension he came away with.

What the law says in an NHS pension divorce

On divorce, a court deciding money questions looks at the matters in section 25(2) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. Section 25B makes clear that these include pension benefits a spouse has or is likely to have. Under section 25(2)(h), the court also weighs any benefit a spouse will lose the chance of acquiring because the marriage ends. For him, that meant a widower’s pension from her scheme.

Under section 24B, the court can make a pension sharing order when it makes the divorce order or at any time after. The order takes effect only once the divorce order is final, and section 21A says it must state a percentage. Section 29 of the Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999 then gives the member’s pension a debit of that percentage of the CETV on the valuation day. The other spouse gets a matching credit.

Dividing an NHS pension: why equal CETVs fell short

A CETV is a capital value, and NHS Pensions works it out using factors from the Scheme Actuary. The offer treated a pound of her NHS CETV and a pound of his private CETV as equal. No one had checked what income each would pay.

The NHS Pensions divorce guide also says a pension credit cannot move to another scheme, so his share would stay inside the NHS scheme. NHS Pensions would turn it into a pension using factors based on his age and gender. It would carry no dependant’s benefits. Payment would usually start at the normal pension age for that part of the scheme, such as 60 in the 1995 Section.

What our family law specialists advised

First, we advised him not to agree any percentage yet. NHS Pensions gives a member’s figures only to the member, unless she signs a letter of authority or a court orders it. So we helped him ask his wife, through her lawyers, to request a CETV on form PD1. As she was still working, her employer also had to complete form PD2. NHS Pensions says it will provide a divorce CETV within three months, so we suggested asking straight away.

Next, we advised him to propose a pensions on divorce expert, often called a PODE, instructed jointly with the fee split. We helped him frame the questions around the NHS rules. What share of each part of her pension would bring his income close to hers? From what age would each part pay? And what was the lost survivor’s pension worth?

In this case, the report found that each pound of her NHS CETV would buy far more retirement income than a pound of his private pension. Equal CETVs would have left him with a much smaller income, so his share had to be larger. We helped him prepare a counter-offer on those figures and advised him on each reply.

A pension sharing order based on income

The couple agreed a pension sharing order at the percentage the report supported. Her rights sat in both the 1995 Section and the 2015 Scheme. So we advised him to check the order had two pension sharing annexes, one for the 1995/2008 Scheme and one for the 2015 Scheme, as NHS Pensions requires. We also suggested sending NHS Pensions the proposed order first, which its guide says can save time and cost.

A judge approved the consent order. Once the divorce was final, she sent NHS Pensions form PD3 with the sealed order, the annexes, the final order and the fee. Today he has a pension of his own in the scheme. Every case turns on its own evidence, so this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from an NHS pension divorce

Treat the CETV as a starting point, and ask what income a share will produce before you agree a percentage. Ask for the CETV early, as NHS Pensions allows up to three months.

If both the 1995/2008 Scheme and the 2015 Scheme are shared, each needs its own annex. Our guides to pension valuation on divorce and financial settlement after divorce explain more. You can also read how we prepare these success stories.

“If only your spouse applied for the divorce and the pension is unsettled, you can ask the court to consider your financial position after the divorce. It must then normally hold back the final order until satisfied that no provision is needed, or that what is offered is reasonable and fair or the best possible, allowing for where you would stand if you outlived your spouse. That matters when a survivor’s pension would be lost with the marriage.”

Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law

Talk it through with us

If an NHS pension is the biggest asset in your divorce, talk to us before you agree a split. A free initial consultation is confidential and carries no obligation. Bring your latest CETV if you have one. Our family law specialists will explain your options.

The legal issue

A husband was divorcing after a long marriage. His wife had worked as a nurse for most of it and still did, and her NHS pension, built up in more than one part of the scheme, was by far the largest asset. His own pension was small. Her side offered a split that would leave them with equal cash equivalent transfer values (CETVs), counting his small private pension. It looked fair, and he was close to accepting it.

The law this rests on

  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2): the matters the court must have regard to when it decides financial orders on divorce.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(h): the value to each party of any benefit which, because the marriage ends, that party will lose the chance of acquiring.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25B(1): those matters include any benefits under a pension arrangement which a party has or is likely to have, and pension benefits a party will lose the chance of acquiring because the marriage ends.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.21A(1)(b): a pension sharing order specifies the percentage value to be transferred.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.24B(1) and (2): the court may make a pension sharing order on making a divorce order or at any time after, and the order does not take effect unless the divorce order has been made final.
  • Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999 s.29(1) and (2): pension sharing puts a debit on the member's rights and gives the former spouse a credit of the same amount. Where the order specifies a percentage, the amount is that percentage of the cash equivalent of the relevant benefits on the valuation day.
  • NHS Pensions, Guide to pensions and divorce or dissolution of a registered civil partnership (TV74): a CETV for divorce is requested on form PD1, with form PD2 from the employer for an active member or one who left in the last 12 months, and is provided within three months; a member is entitled to one free CETV a year; the CETV is calculated using factors provided by the Scheme Actuary; pension credits cannot be transferred to another pension scheme; a pension share does not provide dependant's benefits; pension credit benefits are payable from the normal pension age of the scheme the share was made under (60 in the 1995 Section; 65 or State Pension age, whichever is later, in the 2015 Scheme), or from implementation if later; a separate annex is required for each scheme shared; NHS Pensions has four months to implement a pension sharing order.

How we approached it

We advised him not to agree any percentage before the NHS figures were in. NHS Pensions gives a member's figures only to the member unless she signs a letter of authority or a court orders it, so we helped him ask his wife, through her lawyers, to request a CETV on form PD1. As she was still working, her employer also had to complete form PD2. We suggested the request went in straight away, as NHS Pensions allows up to three months.

We advised him that a pensions on divorce expert (PODE), normally instructed jointly, could answer what a CETV cannot, so he proposed one and offered to split the fee. We helped him frame the questions around the NHS rules: what share of each part of her pension would bring his income close to hers once his own pension was counted, from what age each part would pay, and what the survivor's pension he was losing was worth. We then helped him prepare a counter-offer on the report's figures and advised him on each reply. Finally, we advised him to check that the order had two pension sharing annexes, one for the 1995/2008 Scheme and one for the 2015 Scheme, and suggested that NHS Pensions see the proposed order before it was finalised.

The outcome

The couple agreed a pension sharing order at the percentage the expert's report supported. The expert found that, for this couple, similar retirement incomes needed a larger share for him than equal CETVs would have given. The order had two pension sharing annexes, one for the 1995/2008 Scheme and one for the 2015 Scheme, and NHS Pensions saw the proposed order first. A judge approved the consent order. Once the divorce was final, she sent NHS Pensions form PD3 with the sealed order, the annexes, the final order and the fee, and he now has a pension of his own in the scheme. Every case turns on its own evidence, and this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from this

  • A CETV is a capital value, worked out using the Scheme Actuary's factors. It does not tell you what pension income a share will produce.
  • A pension sharing order states a percentage of the CETV (Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999 s.29(2)). In this case, the expert found that the percentage giving equal CETVs would not have given similar incomes.
  • Before you agree any split of an NHS pension, consider a jointly instructed pensions on divorce expert (PODE).
  • Request the CETV early: NHS Pensions allows up to three months, and a member is entitled to one free CETV a year.
  • If the pension sits in both the 1995/2008 Scheme and the 2015 Scheme, each scheme shared needs its own pension sharing annex. Let NHS Pensions see the proposed order before it is finalised.
  • Count what else ends with the marriage, such as a survivor's pension. The court weighs it under Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(h).

Checked and approved for publication by Iblal Iqbal.

Last reviewed .

Read more about this area of family law

Pension Sharing Order

Author:

Garry Steedman is a family law consultant at Kabir Family Law, specialising in complex divorce, children and property disputes, including TOLATA claims for unmarried couples and cohabitees. He advises on high‑conflict separations, contested children matters and financial settlements, combining clear, straightforward guidance with practical strategies that help clients move forward with confidence. Garry also supports the wider technical trusts of land issues, reviewing complex case files and helping to advise on robust evidence for court and negotiations.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting