His marriage had lasted only a few years, and now his wife said they would split everything 50/50. That included a flat he owned before they met and an inheritance from his late father. This anonymised account explains how our family law specialists advised him on non-matrimonial assets, and what the court would really weigh.
A short marriage and a 50/50 demand
They had no children. Years before the marriage, he bought a small flat with his savings and a mortgage, and let it out throughout. Meanwhile, the couple lived in a home they bought together in joint names.
Then, partway through the marriage, his father died. His share of the estate went into a savings account in his sole name, and he never touched it.
When they separated, her message was short: half of everything, the flat and the inheritance included. He did not want to leave her struggling. Still, he lay awake wondering whether a short marriage meant giving away what his father had left him.
What the law says about non-matrimonial assets
The Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 sets the rules for money on divorce in England and Wales. Under section 25(1), the court must have regard to all the circumstances of the case. The Act never uses the phrase non-matrimonial assets, and it has no 50/50 rule.
Section 25(2) lists the matters the court must weigh. Paragraph (a) covers the income, property and other financial resources each person has or is likely to have. So the court could take both the flat and the inheritance into account.
Other factors pull the other way. Section 25(2)(d) covers the duration of the marriage, and section 25(2)(f) covers each person’s contributions to the welfare of the family. In practice, courts often treat money one spouse brought in from outside the marriage differently from what the couple built together. How far that goes is a judgment for the court, and it depends on the facts.
Needs can outweigh all of this. Section 25(2)(b) requires the court to weigh each person’s financial needs. If the shared assets cannot meet the other spouse’s reasonable needs, the court can still use money from outside the marriage to meet them.
What we advised him to do
First, we told him to hide nothing. Full, honest disclosure was the base of his case. Leaving either asset out would have cost him credibility.
Next, we helped him trace each asset to its source. For the flat, he found the completion statement and mortgage statements showing the debt when they married. For the inheritance, he gathered the grant of probate, the estate accounts and the bank record of his share arriving.
The savings statements mattered most. Every statement since the money arrived showed it had never passed through a joint account, paid family bills or gone towards the shared home.
We were also honest about the weak point. Some rent from the flat had helped with household bills, and his wife could fairly raise that. So we told him to allow for it in his offer.
Finally, we looked at her needs. She would need a home, and her share of the joint equity would not quite buy one. So we advised him to make an early offer that met her reasonable housing needs in full: the larger share of the joint home, topped up with a modest sum from his savings. An offer that already meets the other side’s needs gives them less reason to go to court.
How the settlement protected his non-matrimonial assets
With our guidance, he sent his proposal to her lawyers with a short schedule linking each asset to its documents. After some negotiation, they agreed terms. She received the larger share of the equity in the joint home and a lump sum that let her rehouse. He kept the flat and most of the inheritance.
The terms included a clean break, which the court must consider under section 25A(1). He then sent the agreed terms to the court for approval, again with our guidance. Section 33A lets the court make a consent order in the agreed terms on the information the rules require, unless it has reason to look further. The judge then approved it. Every case turns on its own facts, so this is not a promise about any other family.
What you can take from this
Keep money from outside the marriage separate, and keep the paperwork. An inheritance paid into a joint account or spent on the family home can become much harder to set apart. Disclose everything, because hiding an asset puts the whole settlement at risk.
Above all, take the other person’s needs seriously. An offer that meets them is often the best way to protect the rest.
Our guides cover inheritance and divorce, how family gifts and inheritances are treated and settlements after a short childless marriage. See also how to protect assets in a divorce, and how we prepare these success stories.
“Make sure the clean break reaches your estate as well. On a divorce, the court can order, if it considers it just, that your former spouse may not apply for provision from your estate under the Inheritance Act, which protects what you plan to leave your own family. Until the marriage is dissolved, a will that benefits your spouse still stands, so review it now, together with any pension nomination form.”
Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law
Talk it through with us
If you have heard that everything gets split 50/50, you do not have to accept it at face value. A free initial consultation is confidential and carries no obligation. Tell us what you brought in and what you inherited, and our family law specialists will explain where you stand. Bring any purchase or probate papers you have.
The legal issue
A husband separated after a short marriage with no children. Before the marriage he had bought a flat with his own savings and a mortgage, and he let it out throughout. The couple lived in a home they bought together in joint names. Partway through the marriage his father died, and his share of the estate went into a savings account in his sole name that he never touched. His wife told him everything would be split 50/50, including the flat and the inheritance.
The law this rests on
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(1): the court must have regard to all the circumstances of the case, first consideration being given to the welfare while a minor of any child of the family under eighteen.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(a): the income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources each party has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(b): the financial needs, obligations and responsibilities each party has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(d): the age of each party and the duration of the marriage.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(f): the contributions each party has made or is likely to make to the welfare of the family, including looking after the home or caring for the family.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25A(1): when it decides to make financial orders on or after the divorce order, the court must consider whether it would be appropriate to use its powers so that the financial obligations of each party towards the other end as soon after that order as the court considers just and reasonable.
- Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.33A(1): unless it has reason to inquire further, the court may make a consent order in the agreed terms on the basis only of the prescribed information supplied with the application.
- The Act does not use the phrase non-matrimonial assets and contains no rule that everything is split 50/50. How the court treats money from outside the marriage is a judgment made under these factors.
How we approached it
We advised him to disclose the flat and the inheritance in full, because section 25(2)(a) lets the court consider all the property each person has, and leaving either out would cost him credibility.
We helped him trace each asset to its source: the completion statement and mortgage statements showing the debt on the flat when they married, and the grant of probate, estate accounts and bank record of his inheritance arriving. We asked him to gather every statement on the savings account. Together they showed the money had never been mixed with joint money or used for family spending.
We were honest about the weak point: some rent from the flat had helped with household bills. We then looked at her needs under section 25(2)(b) and advised him to make an early offer that met her reasonable housing needs in full: the larger share of the joint home, topped up with a modest sum from his savings. With our guidance he sent the proposal to her lawyers with a short schedule linking each asset to its documents, and later sent the agreed terms to the court for approval.
The outcome
After some negotiation, the couple agreed terms. She received the larger share of the equity in the joint home and a lump sum that let her rehouse, which met her reasonable needs. He kept his flat and most of his inheritance. The terms included a clean break, and the court approved them as a consent order. Every case turns on its own facts, and this is not a promise about any other family.
What to take from this
- The Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 has no 50/50 rule. The court weighs all the circumstances and the factors in section 25(2).
- Property owned before the marriage and inherited money are still resources the court can take into account under section 25(2)(a), so disclose them in full.
- Keep money from outside the marriage in an account in your own name, and keep the paperwork: purchase records, probate papers and statements.
- Money mixed with joint money or spent on the family home can become much harder to set apart.
- The length of the marriage and each person's contributions are factors the court must weigh.
- Needs still matter. Money from outside the marriage can be used to meet the other person's reasonable needs, so an offer that meets them is often the best way to protect the rest.
Checked and approved for publication by Hannah Overton.
Last reviewed .