Success story
Published 9 mins read12 sections

Two figures sat side by side on her kitchen table. One was the equity in the family home. The other was the transfer value of her husband’s pension, and the two were close. His offer sounded fair: she would keep the house and he would keep his pension, pound for pound. Before she signed, our family law specialists advised her on pension offsetting. This is an anonymised account.

Keeping the home for the children

The marriage had lasted many years. She had cut her working hours to bring up their children, so her own pension was small. He had built up a large defined benefit pension over a long career. She wanted the children to stay in the only home they remembered.

Pushing back, she feared, would mean selling the house. So she was ready to accept before anyone had checked what the pension was worth.

What the law says about pension offsetting

When a court deals with money on divorce, section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 applies. The court looks at all the circumstances, giving first consideration to the welfare of any child of the family under 18. Section 25(2) lists the factors, including each spouse’s resources and needs, now and in the foreseeable future. Section 25B(1) adds that those resources include pension benefits.

The Act has no separate offsetting order. Pension offsetting trades a share of a pension for other assets, often the home, which the court can order one spouse to transfer to the other under section 24. The other route is a pension sharing order under section 21A. It moves a set percentage of the value of one spouse’s pension rights to the other, who then has pension rights of their own. Under section 24B(2), it cannot take effect until the divorce order is final.

Why a CETV is not cash in hand

His offer rested on one figure, the cash equivalent transfer value, or CETV. This is the capital value his scheme puts on his pension rights. As GOV.UK says, you’ll usually pay tax on income from your pensions. House equity is there now, yet it pays no income in retirement.

The Pension Advisory Group produced good practice guidance with the support of the Family Justice Council. It says the cash equivalent is often not considered an appropriate value for offsetting, for example for defined benefit schemes. It adds that a mix of offsetting and pension sharing can resolve a case fairly.

What our family law specialists advised

First, we advised her not to sign yet. Next, we helped her ask for full financial disclosure, including an up to date CETV. We also advised her to ask her husband, as the scheme member, to sign Form P, the pension inquiry form. His scheme would then give its valuation and the details it must provide when a pension sharing order may be made.

Then we advised her to propose a single pensions expert, instructed and paid for by both spouses. We helped her write the questions. What share would give them similar incomes in retirement? And what would a fair offset be if she kept the house?

The report showed that, in income terms, his pension was worth far more than its transfer value suggested. A pound for pound swap would have left her with almost no retirement income of her own.

Meanwhile, a mortgage broker confirmed she could take the mortgage into her sole name. We then helped her prepare a counter-proposal built on the expert’s figures and guided her through each round of negotiation.

A fair offset and a pension of her own

The couple agreed a mix. She kept the family home, and they offset it against part of his pension at the expert’s value instead of the CETV. A smaller pension sharing order gave her a pension of her own.

Under section 33A, the court can make a consent order in the agreed terms on the prescribed information sent with the application. It can still look further if it has reason to think it should. Form D81 asks a couple who offset pension assets to explain briefly how they reached that agreement. It also has space for a valuation that differs from the cash equivalent. With our guidance, they used both to show how they worked out the offset. She sent the papers in, and the court approved the consent order.

Every case turns on its own evidence, so this is not a promise about any other family.

What you can take from pension offsetting

Treat a CETV as a starting point only. If a defined benefit scheme is involved, ask for a report from a pensions expert before you agree any offset.

Compare both routes. Offsetting can let you keep the home, while a pension share gives you income later. A mix of the two can give the fairest result.

Our guides on who gets the house in a divorce and financial settlement after divorce explain more. You can also read how we prepare these success stories.

“Find out early what the scheme charges for a pension share, because the order can say how that charge is split between you. The scheme then has four months to set up your pension, counted from the later of the order taking effect and the day it receives the order, the final divorce order and the details it needs. Check whether the court or one of you is sending those papers, and ask the scheme to confirm receipt.”

Garry Steedman, Family Law Consultant, Kabir Family Law

Talk it through with us

If you are weighing pension offsetting against the family home, you do not need to decide alone. A free initial consultation is confidential and carries no obligation. Bring the offer, the latest CETV and anything the scheme has sent you. Our family law specialists will explain your options before you sign.

The legal issue

A divorcing mother wanted to keep the family home so the children could stay settled. Her husband had a large defined benefit pension; her own pension was small because she had cut her working hours to bring up the children. He offered her the house in return for keeping his pension, pound for pound, because the home equity and his pension's transfer value were close. She was about to agree.

The law this rests on

  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(1): the court must have regard to all the circumstances, first consideration being given to the welfare of any child of the family under 18.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25(2)(a) and (b): each party's resources and financial needs, now and in the foreseeable future.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.25B(1)(a): those matters include benefits under a pension arrangement which a party has or is likely to have.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.24(1)(a): the court may order one party to transfer property, such as the home, to the other.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.21A(1): a pension sharing order makes one party's shareable pension rights subject to pension sharing for the other's benefit and specifies the percentage value to be transferred.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.24B(2): a pension sharing order does not take effect until the divorce order is made final.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.33A(1): the court may make a consent order in the agreed terms on the basis only of the prescribed information sent with the application, unless it has reason to think there are other circumstances it ought to inquire into.
  • Form P (pension inquiry form) and Form D81 (statement of information for a consent order in relation to a financial remedy), published on GOV.UK. Question 13 of Form D81 asks parties who offset pension assets against capital assets to explain briefly how the offsetting agreement was reached.
  • Pension Advisory Group, A Guide to the Treatment of Pensions on Divorce (Second Edition, 2024), supported by the Family Justice Council: the cash equivalent is often not considered an appropriate value for offsetting, and a mix of offsetting and pension sharing can resolve a case fairly.

How we approached it

We advised her not to sign the pound for pound offer until the pension had been properly valued. We helped her ask for full financial disclosure, including an up to date CETV, and advised her to ask her husband to complete Form P, the pension inquiry form.

We advised her to suggest a single pensions expert, instructed by both spouses with the cost shared, and helped her write the questions: what share would give them similar incomes in retirement, and what a fair offset would be if she kept the house. She checked with a mortgage broker that she could take the remaining mortgage into her sole name. We then helped her prepare a counter-proposal built on the expert's figures and guided her through each round of negotiation.

The outcome

The couple agreed a mix of offsetting and pension sharing. She kept the family home, offset against part of his pension at the value the pensions expert gave instead of the CETV, and a smaller pension sharing order gave her a pension of her own. Their statement of information on Form D81 explained how the offset had been worked out and set out the expert's valuation beside the cash equivalent. She sent the papers to the court, and the court approved the consent order. Every case turns on its own evidence, and this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from this

  • A CETV is the capital value the scheme puts on the pension. It is a figure on paper, not money in the bank, and for divorce it is often not a reliable guide to what a defined benefit pension is worth.
  • Ask for a report from a pensions expert before you agree any offset, especially where a defined benefit scheme is involved.
  • Compare offsetting with a pension sharing order under Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 s.21A. A mix of the two is possible where it gives the fairest result.
  • Think about income in retirement as well as the house: home equity pays no pension.
  • Explain how the offset was worked out in the statement of information on Form D81, so the court can see the agreement is fair.

Checked and approved for publication by Hannah Overton.

Last reviewed .

Read more about this area of family law

Pension Sharing Order

Author:

Garry Steedman is a family law consultant at Kabir Family Law, specialising in complex divorce, children and property disputes, including TOLATA claims for unmarried couples and cohabitees. He advises on high‑conflict separations, contested children matters and financial settlements, combining clear, straightforward guidance with practical strategies that help clients move forward with confidence. Garry also supports the wider technical trusts of land issues, reviewing complex case files and helping to advise on robust evidence for court and negotiations.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting