A schedule of allegations and a long wait
The father had applied for an order to spend time with their young child. At the first hearing, the mother explained that he had controlled her for years. He checked her phone and took her wages. He also decided who she could see. There had been two incidents of physical violence. He denied all of it. She felt as though her whole relationship had been turned into a numbered list. The judge asked her to set out each allegation in a schedule, and the father would reply to each one. Then the court would make findings of fact. Only after that would anyone talk about the child’s time with each parent. “I just want to know it will be over,” she told us. “And I want to know he cannot cross-examine me himself.”What the law says about a fact-finding hearing
The court follows Practice Direction 12J of the Family Procedure Rules when abuse is alleged in a children case. Under paragraphs 16 and 17, the judge decides early whether a fact-finding hearing is necessary and proportionate. Paragraph 19 lists the directions the judge should consider. One is a schedule that sets out each allegation, including any pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour, with the reply to it. Our guide to the Scott schedule explains that document. The Domestic Abuse Act 2021 also matters here. Section 3 treats a child who sees, hears or experiences the effects of abuse between their parents as a victim in their own right. Under section 63, a parent who is, or is at risk of being, a victim of domestic abuse by the other parent is treated as eligible for special measures, such as a screen. The 2021 Act also added Part 4B to the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984. In many cases, it stops an alleged abuser from cross-examining the other parent in person. After the hearing, paragraph 29 asks the judge to make findings of fact about the nature and degree of any abuse and to record them in writing. The welfare stage follows under section 1 of the Children Act 1989, where the child’s welfare is the court’s paramount consideration.How we assisted her to prepare her case
First, we explained what happens after a fact-finding hearing. Then we helped her turn years of memories into a clear schedule. Next, we assisted her to set out the coercive and controlling behaviour as a pattern, because a list of separate incidents would have hidden how it worked day to day. Her witness statement followed the schedule, one allegation at a time. We helped her gather the police log from one incident, her GP records and her bank statements, which showed her wages leaving her account each month. Before the hearing, we advised her to ask for special measures. The court agreed to a screen. It also barred the father from questioning her in person, so a qualified advocate put his questions to her instead. On the day, she gave her evidence calmly. Afterwards, she said the screen made it possible.The findings of fact and the order that followed
The judge found the pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour proved, along with one of the physical incidents. However, the judge did not find the other incident proved. The court recorded its findings in writing and sent them to the family court adviser preparing the welfare report. Under paragraph 30, the judge then had to consider whether the welfare report needed new directions in light of the findings. The court directed a report under section 7 of the Children Act 1989, and it addressed the findings directly. In the end, the court made a child arrangements order. The child lives with the mother. The father’s time began as supervised contact at a contact centre, with a later review. Outcomes like this depend entirely on the evidence in each case. Nothing here is a promise about yours.What happens after a fact-finding hearing in your case
So what happens after a fact-finding hearing? The findings set the frame for every decision about the child that follows. Under paragraphs 35 to 37 of Practice Direction 12J, the court should make sure that any contact will not expose the child to an unmanageable risk of harm. What the judge can find depends on a focused schedule and on evidence tied to each allegation. Our guide to fact-finding hearings in the family court explains the process in more detail. You can also read about non-molestation orders, which protect a parent while a case goes on.“Once findings are made, the case moves on from what happened to what is safe. Keep the written findings beside you when you speak to the family court adviser, who should already have a copy. Think through how contact could work in practice, such as handovers at a contact centre, and say what would help you feel safe. Where abuse has been found, the court should weigh both parents’ conduct, towards each other and the child, and its impact.”
Hannah Overton, Complex Children Specialist, Kabir Family Law
Talk to us before your hearing
You may be the parent who raised the allegations, or the parent answering them. Either way, the months before a hearing can feel endless. A free initial consultation lets you explain your situation in confidence. One of our family law specialists will then tell you what happens after a fact-finding hearing in a case like yours. You can read how we prepare these success stories, or contact us to book a free consultation.The legal issue
A father applied for an order to spend time with his young child. At the first hearing, the mother said he had controlled her for years: checking her phone, taking her wages and deciding who she could see. She also described two incidents of physical violence. He denied everything.
The court directed a fact-finding hearing. Before anyone could decide the child's arrangements, the judge had to decide what had happened. The mother feared she would not be believed, and that she would have to face him in the witness box.
The law this rests on
- Practice Direction 12J FPR 2010 paras 16 and 17 - the court decides as soon as possible whether a fact-finding hearing is necessary.
- Practice Direction 12J para 19 - directions the court should consider, including whether the key facts can be set out in a schedule of the allegations and the response to each.
- Practice Direction 12J para 29 - the court makes findings on the nature and degree of any domestic abuse and records them in writing; they are sent to the officer preparing the section 7 report.
- Practice Direction 12J para 30 - after the hearing, the court considers whether to give further directions about the section 7 report.
- Practice Direction 12J paras 35 to 37 - the court should ensure any order for contact will not expose the child to an unmanageable risk of harm.
- Children Act 1989 s.1(1) - the child's welfare is the court's paramount consideration.
- Children Act 1989 s.1(3)(e) - any harm the child has suffered or is at risk of suffering.
- Children Act 1989 s.7 - welfare reports.
- Children Act 1989 s.8 - child arrangements orders.
- Domestic Abuse Act 2021 s.3 - a child who sees, hears or experiences the effects of domestic abuse, and is related to either party, is a victim in their own right.
- Domestic Abuse Act 2021 s.63 - a party who is, or is at risk of being, a victim of domestic abuse by another party, a party's relative or a witness is treated as eligible for special measures.
- Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984 Part 4B (added by Domestic Abuse Act 2021 s.65) - limits cross-examination in person where domestic abuse is alleged.
How we approached it
We helped the mother turn years of memories into a focused schedule of allegations. We assisted her to keep it to the matters that mattered most for the child, and we assisted her to set out the coercive and controlling behaviour as a pattern, so the judge could see how it worked day to day.
Her witness statement followed the schedule, one allegation at a time. We helped her gather supporting evidence, including a police log, her GP records and bank statements showing her wages leaving her account.
We also advised her to ask the court early for special measures. She gave her evidence from behind a screen. The court barred the father from questioning her in person, so a qualified advocate put his questions to her.
The outcome
The judge found the pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour proved, along with one of the two physical incidents. The other incident was not found proved. The court recorded its findings in writing and sent them to the family court adviser preparing the welfare report.
That report addressed the findings directly. The court then made a child arrangements order: the child lives with the mother, and the father's time began as supervised contact at a contact centre, with a later review.
Outcomes of this kind turn entirely on the evidence in the individual case. Nothing here is a prediction or a promise about any other case.
What to take from this
- A fact-finding hearing is not automatic. Under Practice Direction 12J paras 16 and 17, the court first decides whether one is necessary.
- The schedule decides what the hearing is about. Keep it focused on what matters for the child.
- Practice Direction 12J para 19 lets the schedule set out coercive and controlling behaviour as a pattern, so the judge sees the whole picture.
- Ask for special measures early. Under Domestic Abuse Act 2021 s.63, a party at risk of domestic abuse from another party is treated as eligible for special measures.
- Findings do not decide contact on their own. They set the frame for the welfare report and for the decision under Practice Direction 12J paras 35 to 37.
Checked and approved for publication by Garry Steedman.
Last reviewed .
Read more about this area of family law
How to Apply for a Fact-Finding Hearing When Domestic Abuse Affects Your Children