Family law guide

Published Last reviewed 16 mins read 11 sections

Part of: Interim and Final Care Orders: What Happens and How to Protect Your Position

An issues resolution hearing (IRH) is the care proceedings hearing that follows the local authority’s final evidence and care plan. At it, the judge finds out which points are still in dispute and narrows them. If nothing important remains to argue about, the IRH can become the final hearing and the case ends there.

In England and Wales the IRH is Stage 3 of the Public Law Outline, set out in Practice Direction 12A. That outline is the court’s timetable for care cases. This guide is for parents and relatives facing an IRH. It covers what everyone must file first and what the judge must do on the day. It also explains two Court of Appeal decisions from October 2025 about ending a care case at this stage.

Key takeaways

  • A care case should finish within 26 weeks of issue. The court can extend that only where an extension is necessary to resolve the case justly (Children Act 1989, s.32).
  • Every party’s lawyer, and any parent without a lawyer, meets at least 7 business days before the IRH. Together they list what is still in dispute (PD12A, Stage 3).
  • The judge can use the IRH as the final hearing. In October 2025, though, the Court of Appeal set aside final care orders made that way. A real factual dispute was still live, and an assessment was still due (Re H [2025] EWCA Civ 1342).
  • Agreement does not settle threshold. The judge must decide that the local authority has proved the grounds for a care order, and say why (Re D [2025] EWCA Civ 1362, para 41).
  • In our experience, parents lose most ground here by arriving without a list of what they accept and dispute.

Has the final care plan just arrived? You can book a free initial consultation with one of our specialists before the advocates’ meeting.

What is an issues resolution hearing?

It is the last main hearing before any final hearing in care proceedings. By then the court should have the assessments and the local authority’s final statement and care plan. It should also have the children’s guardian’s view of them.

The Public Law Outline sets the order of hearings. First comes the case management hearing, no earlier than day 12 and no later than day 18. These are business days, and the day of issue counts as day 1. A further case management hearing takes place only where necessary. Next comes the IRH, on the date the court directs, and a final hearing follows if one is still needed (PD12A, Stages 2 and 3). Our guide to interim and final care orders sets out the whole timeline. For the earlier case management stage, see our guide to directions hearings. Before all of it comes the pre-proceedings letter (PLO).

Time limits apply throughout. The court must timetable the case to finish without delay, and in any event within 26 weeks of issue. It can extend that period only if an extension is necessary to resolve the case justly (Children Act 1989, s.32(1)(a) and (5)). Each extension lasts no more than eight weeks, and courts should not grant them routinely (s.32(7) and (8)).

What must everyone file before the IRH?

The local authority files its final evidence and care plan, and the other parties respond to them. Alongside these, the court usually directs a threshold document and a Case Analysis from the children’s guardian. It sets every deadline at the case management hearing (PD12A, Stage 2).

  • The final care plan. The local authority must prepare a care plan and keep it under review while the case runs (Children Act 1989, s.31A). Before making a care order, the court must consider the plan’s permanence provisions (s.31(3A) and (3B)). These say where the child will live long term and how that meets the child’s needs.
  • A threshold document. The local authority sets out the facts it relies on. Parents usually have to say which facts they accept and which they dispute.
  • Your own evidence, where the court has directed it. This can include proof of change since the assessments, such as test results or letters from people working with you.
  • The guardian’s Case Analysis. In it, the guardian outlines the case from the point of view of the child’s best interests. It covers threshold, parenting capability and early permanence, among other things (PD12A, para 7.1).

The advocates’ meeting, a week or more before

Every party’s lawyer meets at least 7 business days before the IRH, and so does any parent acting without a lawyer. They review the evidence and each side’s position. Then they list the issues still in dispute, the evidence needed to resolve them and whether anyone should give oral evidence. Afterwards, the local authority’s lawyer tells the court the outcome. That lawyer also files a draft case management order by 11am on the business day before the hearing (PD12A, Stage 3).

This meeting is where your instructions count. In Re H, the Court of Appeal thought it unlikely that the meeting a week before had been productive. One parent’s lawyer had no instructions, and the other parent’s lawyer was not there (para 12).

What does the judge do at the IRH?

The judge identifies the key issues still in dispute and how far the hearing can resolve or narrow them, including by hearing evidence. The judge also considers whether the IRH can serve as the final hearing (PD12A, Stage 3).

If the case does not finish that day, the judge identifies the evidence the final hearing will need. Final directions follow. They cover any threshold agreement or statement of facts still in issue, the final evidence and care plan, and witness templates. They also cover skeleton arguments, the court bundle and the final hearing date. Finally, the judge issues a case management order.

Judges should treat the IRH as a serious hearing. In July 2024 the President of the Family Division said the judge needs time to prepare it like a final hearing. He added that the listing should allow time for short evidence. His 2022 guidance says that an adjournment, or more evidence, at that stage must be necessary to decide the remaining issues. The Court of Appeal quoted both in Re H, paras 33 and 35. Cafcass warns that the hearing is likely to be emotional, and that you will need to think carefully about your position (Cafcass).

Can the issues resolution hearing become the final hearing?

Yes. If taking evidence at the IRH can reasonably resolve the issue the case turns on, the court must take that flexible approach (PD12A, para 2.3). Cafcass adds that the case may end at this hearing if you, the guardian and the local authority all agree the plan.

The Court of Appeal has long accepted that a judge may decide a care application at the IRH in suitable cases. The necessary evidence must first be before the court (Re J [2017] EWCA Civ 398, para 17, quoted in Re H, para 31).

When ending the case early is unfair to a parent

Re H shows the limits. By the issues resolution hearing, the case had reached its 128th week and more than 1,700 pages of documents. The judge made final care orders at a 45-minute hearing, over the parents’ objection (paras 2 and 40). The Court of Appeal set aside the orders for the two younger children. It gave four reasons why ending the case at the IRH was unfair (paras 39 to 42).

First, the father had filed evidence, including hair strand tests, that he had dealt with his drinking. That raised a material factual issue that needed a trial. Second, the local authority’s own position statement had accepted the need for a final hearing, so its change of stance took the parents by surprise. Third, the evidence was incomplete. The final assessment of the proposed long-term carers was not due for another month, and DBS checks were still outstanding. Fourth, the judgment barely dealt with a care plan that cut the father’s contact with one child from weekly to four times a year. The court must consider contact before it makes a care order (paras 42 and 43).

When a judge does end a disputed case at the IRH, the judgment must explain why. It should also deal with threshold, each realistic option for the child, the permanence plan, the welfare checklist and contact (Re H, para 46). Such a judgment can be shorter than one after a full trial, but it still needs a clear structure (para 47).

Does the judge still decide threshold if nobody argues about it?

Yes. The court itself must find threshold proved and say why, since neither agreement nor default can settle it (Re D, para 41). Threshold means the child is suffering, or is likely to suffer, significant harm. That harm must be attributable to care that falls short of what it would be reasonable to expect a parent to give, or to the child being beyond parental control (Children Act 1989, s.31(2)).

In Re D, the parents chose not to attend the IRH. The judge made care and placement orders that day, and his threshold reasoning leaned on their lack of engagement. On appeal, the court held that disengagement could not, as a bald fact, prove threshold (para 50). It set the orders aside. Reasons still matter when parents stay away, it said, because the child may one day read the judgment (para 48). The court also doubted a standard order that treats a parent who files no response as accepting the threshold allegations. It called that “not in my view a safe basis” (para 57).

Why staying away from the hearing does not help

The parents in Re D had notice of the hearing and had been warned more than once that it could end the case. The Court of Appeal found it entirely understandable that the judge concluded the proceedings that day (para 38). Their appeal succeeded because the judgment made no threshold findings and gave almost no reasons for the orders (paras 39 and 53). For what threshold means in practice, see our guide to care orders.

Before an issues resolution hearing: a young boy holds on to his parent's leg
The final care plan can feel like the end of the road. What you accept and what you dispute still matters at the IRH.

We advised a mother whose son had lived in foster care for most of the proceedings. Two weeks before the issues resolution hearing, the final care plan proposed long-term fostering. An assessment of her sister as a kinship carer was still due. The mother accepted most of the threshold document but denied two allegations she had always disputed. We helped her separate the two parts of her case. Her written response conceded the facts she accepted, so the hearing did not turn on them. Her position was that the court should not decide where her son would live until the local authority filed her sister’s assessment. The judge made threshold findings on the agreed facts and listed a short final hearing for after the assessment. What happens in any case turns on its own facts.

Issues resolution hearing check: what is still in dispute?

Three answers show the likely shape of your IRH and the point most likely to need advice. This page does not send or store anything you choose.

0 of 3 answered

Where do you stand on the threshold document?
What do you think of the final care plan?
Is all the evidence the court ordered now in?

Answer all three to see the likely shape of your IRH

  • ThresholdWhat the judge still has to decide about the facts.
  • Care planWhich part of the plan is really in issue.
  • EvidenceWhether the court has what it needs to finish.
The call this check cannot make What you should accept, and what you should contest.

Book a free initial consultation

Expert Tip

Before the advocates’ meeting, write one page with three headings: what I accept, what I dispute, and what I need more evidence on. Put each threshold fact and each part of the care plan under one of them, including contact. Give it to your lawyer a few days before the meeting. That page is your instructions. Without it, your lawyer goes into the meeting guessing, and the meeting sets the agenda for the IRH.

Hannah Overton, Complex Children Specialist & Client Support

How should a parent prepare for the issues resolution hearing?

Read the final evidence and care plan as soon as they arrive. Then give your lawyer a written list of what you accept and dispute, well before the advocates’ meeting. The issues listed at that meeting go to the court before the IRH.

  • Go through the threshold document line by line. Mark each fact as accepted, disputed or not known to you. The judge has to decide threshold either way, so a disputed fact needs evidence behind it.
  • Note every part of the care plan you disagree with. That includes where your child will live, contact with you and with brothers and sisters, and the plan if a placement breaks down. Before making a care order, the court must consider the contact arrangements and invite comments on them (Children Act 1989, s.34(11)).
  • Gather proof of change since the assessments, such as test results or attendance letters. Ask your lawyer whether you need the court’s permission to file it.
  • Name relatives or friends who could care for your child as early as you can. A late name can mean a late assessment. Our guides to special guardianship orders and kinship care explain those options.
  • Speak to the guardian. Cafcass says guardians talk to parents before the case management hearing and again before the IRH. Our guide to the children’s guardian explains the role.
  • Tell your lawyer early if you want to give evidence. Anyone who expects oral evidence at the IRH must tell the court well in advance (PD12A, para 2.5).
  • Attend. Re D shows that a judge can conclude the case at the IRH when parents who had notice stay away.

How is the IRH different from a dispute resolution appointment?

The issues resolution hearing belongs to care proceedings brought by a local authority. A dispute resolution appointment (DRA) belongs to a private dispute between family members about a child. Even so, the judge’s tasks at each are almost word for word the same: identify the key issues, consider using the hearing as the final hearing, resolve or narrow issues by hearing evidence, then give final directions (PD12B, para 19.3).

The IRH and the dispute resolution appointment compared
PointIRH (care proceedings)DRA (private law)
Who brought the caseA local authority, asking for a care or supervision orderA parent or another family member, usually about who the child lives with or spends time with
What the court must find firstThreshold: significant harm, suffered or likely, attributable to care below what it would be reasonable to expect a parent to give, or to the child being beyond parental control (s.31(2))No threshold. The child’s welfare is the court’s paramount consideration (s.1(1))
Main evidence before itFinal evidence, the final care plan and the guardian’s Case AnalysisA section 7 or other expert report, or a parenting programme (PD12B, para 19.1)
Time limit26 weeks from issue unless extended (s.32)No fixed limit, though the court must treat delay as likely to prejudice the child’s welfare (s.1(2))
Report writer at the hearingThe guardian takes part for the child throughoutThe section 7 author attends only if the court directs it (PD12B, para 19.2)

For a private dispute that has only just started, see our guide to the first hearing dispute resolution appointment.

Issues resolution hearing: frequently asked questions

How long after the IRH is the final hearing?

There is no fixed gap. The judge lists the final hearing at the IRH, within the case timetable. That timetable aims to finish within 26 weeks of issue, unless the court extends it by up to eight weeks at a time (Children Act 1989, s.32(5) and (8)).

Do I have to attend the IRH?

You should. Cafcass explains that the parties are ordered to attend court hearings so that the judge can listen to each of them. In Re D the judge decided the case at the IRH when the parents stayed away. The Court of Appeal found that understandable, although it set the orders aside for other reasons (Re D, para 38).

Will I have to give evidence at the IRH?

Possibly. The judge can resolve or narrow issues by hearing evidence at the IRH. Anyone who expects to need oral evidence must tell the court well in advance and ask for directions (PD12A, para 2.5).

What is an advocates’ meeting?

It is a meeting of every party’s lawyer, and any parent without a lawyer, at least 7 business days before the IRH. They review the evidence, list the issues still in dispute and identify the evidence the court will need. The local authority’s lawyer then tells the court the outcome (PD12A, Stage 3).

Can the judge adjourn the IRH?

Only where it is necessary. The President’s 2022 guidance says an adjournment or further evidence at the IRH must be necessary to decide the remaining issues (quoted in Re H, para 33). If an assessment that could change the plan is still outstanding, raise it before the advocates’ meeting.

An issues resolution hearing listed? Get advice before the advocates’ meeting

The risk at this stage is a care case that ends sooner than you expected. A judge can make final orders at the IRH. The order can also record a threshold fact as agreed when you never meant to accept it. If an assessment is still outstanding, or you dispute where your child will live, make that clear before the advocates’ meeting.

A free initial consultation is a conversation with a specialist. They give you initial advice tailored to your circumstances, including what to raise before the hearing. It does not include drafting or reviewing documents.

Book a free initial consultation or call 0330 094 5880.

You can also read our guides to discharging a care order and the parenting assessment, or return to our guide to interim and final care orders.

General information about the law in England and Wales, not advice on your circumstances.

Written by

Hannah Overton is a complex children specialist at Kabir Family Law, focusing on child arrangements disputes, fact‑finding hearings and cases involving CAFCASS and safeguarding concerns in the family courts of England and Wales. She has extensive experience supporting parents through allegation‑heavy proceedings and creates clear, practical resources that explain court processes, evidence preparation and contact arrangements. Hannah also works closely with the client services team to ensure families receive informed, compassionate guidance at every stage of their case.

Related Services

8 of 41 guides — scroll sideways for more

Our videos

Short videos from the Kabir Family Law team, explaining family law in plain English.

View all

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting