For two years the money arrived on the first of each month. Then her ex stopped paying child maintenance, with no warning and no reply to her messages. After the third missed month she texted him four words: no money, no Saturdays.
She was in her late twenties, and their daughter was four. Since the split, the little girl had spent every Saturday with her dad from ten until six, plus a video call on Wednesday evenings. Neither parent had ever been to court. A Child Maintenance Service calculation set the amount, and he paid it under Direct Pay by standing order.
For six weeks there were no Saturdays, though every Friday night her daughter still asked whether tomorrow was a Daddy day. Then her ex messaged to say he would see her in court. She asked us: if he will not pay for her, why should he have her on Saturdays?
Her ex stopped paying child maintenance: could she stop contact?
Not for that reason, we told her. Time with a child does not depend on paying maintenance. GOV.UK calls child maintenance a financial arrangement between the parents and says that arrangements to see your child happen separately.
A court takes the same view. As a parent, her ex could ask the court for a child arrangements order, and it would treat their daughter’s welfare as its paramount consideration (section 1 of the Children Act 1989).
Opposing him would bring in section 1(2A), which requires the court to presume, unless shown otherwise, that his involvement furthers their daughter’s welfare, provided he can take part without putting her at risk of harm. Unpaid child maintenance says nothing about that risk.
Keeping a young child from a safe parent to press for money could count against her, we warned, because the court would look at how well each parent can meet a child’s needs (section 1(3)(f)).
With no order in place, there was nothing for him to enforce yet. Once a child arrangements order exists, breaking it without a reasonable excuse can lead to an enforcement order (section 11J). Our guide to the reasons to stop child contact sets out what a court accepts and what it rejects.
Saturdays first, then the money
We advised her to restart contact that week, without waiting for a court. We helped her write a short message giving Saturday’s time and place, with nothing about money in it. If a judge ever asked, she could show she had put things right herself.
While a case is on Direct Pay, GOV.UK says the Child Maintenance Service cannot take action. So she signed in to her CMS account, reported the missed payments and asked to move to Collect and Pay. We helped her mark up the bank statements showing each month of unpaid child maintenance.
Under section 4(2A) of the Child Support Act 1991, the CMS can arrange collection without his agreement if it concludes that he is unlikely to pay otherwise.
On Collect and Pay, we explained, the CMS adds a 20% fee to each of his payments and takes 4% off what she receives. She thought 4% a fair price for never chasing him.
Collection also opens the way to enforcement. A deduction from earnings order can take arrears and future payments from his wages (section 31). Or the CMS can take regular deductions from a bank account (section 32A).
If wage deductions are unsuitable or have not worked, the CMS can ask a magistrates’ court for a liability order (section 33). The paying parent pays an extra fee when the CMS uses these powers. Our child maintenance guide explains the calculation.
Saturdays back, and the money moving
On Friday night her question finally got a yes. Contact restarted the next morning, and the Wednesday calls resumed too. Her ex never applied to court.
Within a few weeks the CMS moved the case to Collect and Pay, so the parents no longer talk about money. His employer now takes the payments from his wages, plus an extra amount each month until the unpaid child maintenance is paid off.
We changed some details to protect the family, who agreed to us sharing this. A different family’s facts could lead somewhere else. Read how we prepare these success stories.
Stopped paying child maintenance? What to do now
If the other parent has stopped paying child maintenance, keep contact going or restart it now, and leave money out of any message about visits.
Gather bank statements for every missed or short payment. On Direct Pay, report them in your CMS account and ask to move to Collect and Pay.
With only a private arrangement, apply to the CMS through the Get help arranging child maintenance tool on GOV.UK. Its powers only reach payments due under its own calculation.
If a court order sets out contact, keep to it. A missed payment is not a safety reason, and a court is unlikely to accept it as a reasonable excuse.
“When the visits restart, give a young child a short, true explanation, such as ‘Daddy is coming on Saturday’, and keep money out of it. A child who hears that visits stopped over money may decide it was their fault. Decline cash at handovers and point to the CMS, so the record stays clear. And if payments stopped because the other parent’s income fell by 25% or more, either parent can report that change.”
Iblal Iqbal, Partner & Family Law Strategist, Kabir Family Law
Thinking of cancelling the next visit?
If your ex stopped paying child maintenance and the next visit is days away, speak to us first. The first consultation costs nothing. Tell us which payments are missing and whether there is an order, and we will help you word the message about visits and plan the CMS steps.
The legal issue
A mother in her late twenties and the father of their four-year-old daughter had separated without going to court. The girl lived with her mother and saw her father every Saturday, with a video call on Wednesday evenings. A Child Maintenance Service calculation set his payments, which he made by standing order under Direct Pay. After three months with no payments, she stopped the Saturday visits. Six weeks later he said he would see her in court, and she asked us whether she could keep contact stopped until he paid.
The law this rests on
- Children Act 1989 s.1(1): when a court determines any question with respect to the upbringing of a child, the child's welfare is the court's paramount consideration.
- Children Act 1989 s.1(2A), (4)(a) and (6)(a): where the court is considering a section 8 order that is opposed, it presumes, unless the contrary is shown, that involvement of a parent who can be involved without putting the child at risk of suffering harm will further the child's welfare.
- Children Act 1989 s.1(3)(f): the welfare checklist includes how capable each parent is of meeting the child's needs.
- Children Act 1989 s.8(1) and s.10(4)(a): a child arrangements order regulates with whom and when a child is to live, spend time or otherwise have contact, and any parent is entitled to apply for one.
- Children Act 1989 s.11J(1) to (3): where a child arrangements order has been made, the court may make an enforcement order imposing unpaid work if it is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that a person failed to comply with it, but not if that person had a reasonable excuse.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.1(1) and (3): each parent of a qualifying child is responsible for maintaining the child, and the non-resident parent has a duty to make the payments a maintenance calculation requires.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.4(2) and (2A): once a maintenance calculation has been made, the person with care can apply for collection and enforcement. Collection can be arranged without the paying parent's agreement if the Secretary of State is satisfied that maintenance is otherwise unlikely to be paid in accordance with the calculation.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.31(2) and (3): a deduction from earnings order can secure arrears, future payments, or both.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.32A(1) and (2): an order for regular deductions from a bank account can be made where a person has failed to pay child support maintenance, for arrears, future payments, or both.
- Child Support Act 1991 s.33(1) to (3): the Secretary of State can apply to a magistrates' court for a liability order where payments are due and unpaid and a deduction from earnings order is inappropriate or has proved ineffective.
- GOV.UK (Child Maintenance Service): child maintenance is a financial arrangement between the parents, and making arrangements to see your child happens separately. Both parents are responsible for the costs of raising their children, even if they do not see them.
- GOV.UK (Unpaid child maintenance; Making and receiving payments): the Child Maintenance Service cannot take action while you are on Direct Pay, and you can ask to move to Collect and Pay. Collect and Pay fees are 20% added to the payment for paying parents and 4% taken off for receiving parents. The paying parent pays an extra fee if enforcement action is used.
How we approached it
We advised her that money and contact are separate questions, that unpaid maintenance is not a reason a court accepts for keeping a child from a safe parent, and that stopping contact could count against her if he ever asked a court for a child arrangements order. We advised her to restart contact that week and helped her write a short message giving the time and place, with nothing about money in it. For the money, we explained that the Child Maintenance Service cannot take action while a case is on Direct Pay. She reported the missed payments in her online account and asked to move to Collect and Pay, and we helped her mark up the bank statements showing each missed month. We also explained the collection fees and the powers the CMS has to recover arrears.
The outcome
Contact restarted the following Saturday, and the Wednesday video calls came back the same week. The father did not apply to court. Within a few weeks the CMS moved the case to Collect and Pay. His employer now takes the payments from his wages, with an extra amount each month towards the missed months, and the parents no longer discuss money with each other. Other families' facts may produce other results.
What to take from this
- Unpaid child maintenance is not a reason to keep a child from a safe parent. GOV.UK treats money and arrangements to see your child as separate.
- If a court decides a disputed application about your child, it puts the child's welfare first and presumes, unless shown otherwise, that involvement of a parent who can take part safely furthers the child's welfare.
- Restart contact yourself with a written message, and leave money out of it.
- On Direct Pay the Child Maintenance Service cannot take action. Report missed payments in your online account, keep your bank statements, and ask to move to Collect and Pay.
- Collect and Pay adds a 20% fee to each payment for the paying parent and takes 4% off for the receiving parent.
- The CMS can recover arrears from wages or take regular deductions from a bank account. Where wage deductions are unsuitable or have not worked, it can ask a magistrates' court for a liability order.
- Where a court has already made a child arrangements order, keep to it while the money is sorted out. Breaking it without a reasonable excuse can lead to an enforcement order.
Checked and approved for publication by Hannah Overton.
Last reviewed .