The text came on a Saturday: “She’s fine, it was a nip, she went near his bowl.” Under a cartoon plaster on her daughter’s forearm, the mother found four puncture marks. On Monday she rang us. “My ex’s dog bit my child, and he says it was her fault. Must I send her back?”
A bite, and a text calling it a nip
Under a court order made when the parents separated, their daughter, now at primary school, lived mainly at her mother’s and went to her dad’s on alternate weekends. Since the split he had bought a large young dog, and at first she adored it.
The dog bit her as she bent to hug it while it ate. Her father cleaned the wound and sent the text. Her mother took her to an urgent treatment centre, where a nurse closed the bite with paper strips and prescribed antibiotics. Later the girl said, without being asked, “I only wanted to cuddle him.”
Asked to keep the dog in another room during contact, he replied within minutes: “He lives here. She needs to learn how to behave around dogs. I’m not shutting him away in his own home.” The mother wanted the weekends to go on without the dog.
Can contact go on after my ex’s dog bit my child?
Often it can, if the dog stays away. Our reasons to stop child contact guide shows where courts draw the line between limiting and stopping contact. Nothing suggested the father would harm her. The risk was the dog that bit her, and his refusal to manage it.
Section 1(1) of the Children Act 1989 makes her welfare the court’s paramount consideration. Where a change is opposed, the court weighs any harm she has suffered or risks suffering. Unless the contrary is shown, it also presumes that keeping a parent involved, where that is safe, will further her welfare.
Her existing order could deal with the dog. Section 11(7)(b) of the Children Act 1989 lets the court add conditions a parent must keep to, and any parent can apply to vary an order. She asked about a prohibited steps order. Section 9(5), we explained, bars one where a child arrangements order could achieve the same result.
Under section 3 of the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991, an owner whose dog is dangerously out of control anywhere in England or Wales, even at home, is guilty of an offence, an aggravated one if it injures someone. The exemption for homes applies only where the person at risk is, or is believed to be, a trespasser, which a child on a contact weekend is not. She chose not to call the police.
What we advised while the order stood
Even with a bite to point to, she could not rewrite the weekends alone. If he sought enforcement over a weekend she held back, she would have to prove a reasonable excuse (section 11J). So we advised her to offer the safest contact she could: both weekend days, ten until six, anywhere but his house.
That week we helped her start a record of the dog bite: daily photos of the healing arm, the discharge letter, both of his messages unedited, and a dated note of her daughter’s words.
Next, we helped her write to the father asking for one change: during contact the dog stays behind a closed door or at another address, and their daughter is never left alone with it. Overnights would restart once he agreed.
He took the daytime visits but refused the condition. She attended a MIAM, the meeting about mediation usually needed first, but he would not mediate. We then helped her complete form C100 for a variation. She asked for the condition to start at the first hearing as an interim order (section 11(3)). Our guide to a variation order in family court covers each step.
A closed door, written into the order
At that first hearing his offer was a stair gate. She had watched the dog clear his garden gate, and said so calmly. By the end of the hearing he accepted her condition, and the court varied the order by consent. Overnight weekends restarted that Friday.
In practice he leaves the dog with his brother on contact weekends. Months after the dog bit her, the girl still asks after it. To keep the family private we have changed small facts, and her mother agreed to us sharing this account. Every family differs, so this is no forecast for yours.
First steps if your ex’s dog bit your child
Get the dog bite checked and keep the clinician’s notes. Photograph the wound as it heals and save every message whole. Note your child’s own words with the date, without questioning them.
If an order sets contact, do not simply keep your child home. Offer the safest contact you can, ask in writing for the one change you need and take advice this week. Without agreement, a MIAM usually comes first, then form C100. Our child arrangements order guide explains what an order can say. See also how we write up client stories.
“Before you propose a condition, walk through a whole contact weekend, from the handover to the drive and a trip to the park. A dog shut away at home can still ride in the back of the car, so the wording should cover wherever contact happens. If your child is still frightened of dogs weeks later, ask your GP for support.”
Hannah Overton, Complex Children Specialist, Kabir Family Law
Before the next weekend comes round
If your ex’s dog bit your child, have the medical notes and your order to hand when you contact us. That first conversation costs nothing, and we keep it confidential.
The legal issue
The parents had parted some years before. Their daughter, now at primary school, lived mainly at her mother's under a child arrangements order, going to her father's on alternate weekends. After the split he bought a large young dog. During one of his weekends it bit her forearm as she bent to hug it while it was eating. He called it a nip, but she needed treatment at an urgent treatment centre, with paper strips and antibiotics. When her mother asked him to keep the dog in another room during contact, he refused: the dog lived there, and he would not shut it away.
The law this rests on
- Children Act 1989 s.1(1): the child's welfare is the court's paramount consideration.
- Children Act 1989 s.1(3)(e) and (4)(a): where the court is considering whether to make, vary or discharge a section 8 order and that is opposed, it has regard to the welfare checklist, including any harm the child has suffered or is at risk of suffering.
- Children Act 1989 s.1(2A) and (6): in those cases the court presumes, unless the contrary is shown, that involvement of a parent who can be involved without putting the child at risk of suffering harm will further the child's welfare.
- Children Act 1989 s.8(2): a section 8 order includes any order varying or discharging a child arrangements order, prohibited steps order or specific issue order.
- Children Act 1989 s.9(5)(a): no court may make a prohibited steps order with a view to achieving a result which could be achieved by making a child arrangements order.
- Children Act 1989 s.10(4)(a): any parent is entitled to apply for any section 8 order.
- Children Act 1989 s.11(3): the court may make a section 8 order at any time during the proceedings, even though it is not in a position to dispose finally of them.
- Children Act 1989 s.11(7)(b): a section 8 order may impose conditions which must be complied with by a parent of the child, or a person named in the order as someone the child is to live, spend time or otherwise have contact with, where the conditions are expressed to apply to them.
- Children Act 1989 s.11J(3) and (4): the court may not make an enforcement order if it is satisfied that the person had a reasonable excuse for failing to comply; that person must prove the excuse on the balance of probabilities.
- Children and Families Act 2014 s.10(1): before making a relevant family application, a person must attend a family mediation information and assessment meeting (MIAM). Family Procedure Rules 2010 r.3.6 and Practice Direction 3A para 12(1)(a): the MIAM requirement applies to applications for section 8 orders unless a MIAM exemption under r.3.8 applies. Under para 12(2) it does not apply to an application for a consent order, or to one about a child in ongoing emergency, care or supervision proceedings or subject to an emergency protection, care or supervision order.
- Form C100 (GOV.UK): used to apply for a child arrangements order, and also to apply to vary or discharge an order.
- Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 s.3(1): if a dog is dangerously out of control in any place in England or Wales, whether or not a public place, the owner (and any person in charge of it) is guilty of an offence, and of an aggravated offence if the dog injures any person.
- Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 s.3(1A) and (1B): a person is not guilty in a householder case, which applies only where the dog is in or partly in a dwelling (or forces accommodation) and the person in relation to whom it is out of control is there, or entering, as a trespasser, or the defendant believed them to be.
How we approached it
We advised her against keeping her daughter at home and saying nothing, because a court order set the weekends and, if he sought enforcement, she would have to prove a reasonable excuse for any weekend she held back. She offered daytime contact on both weekend days, anywhere except the father's house, until the dog was dealt with. We helped her keep a record while it was fresh: daily photos of the healing bite, the discharge letter, the father's messages kept whole and unedited, and her daughter's own words with the date. We helped her write to the father asking for one change: during contact the dog would stay behind a closed door or at another address, and the child would never be left alone with it. When he refused, and would not mediate after her MIAM, she made an application on form C100 to change the order, and we guided her through it. She asked for the condition to be added, and for an interim order at the first hearing. We explained why a prohibited steps order was not the route: a condition on the child arrangements order could do the job.
The outcome
At that first hearing his offer was a stair gate. The mother explained calmly that she had watched the dog clear his garden gate. By the end of the hearing he agreed to her condition, and the court varied the order by consent: whenever their daughter is with him, the dog stays behind a closed door or at another address, and she is never left alone with it. Overnight weekends restarted that Friday, and in practice he leaves the dog with his brother on contact weekends. Every family differs, so this is no forecast for yours.
What to take from this
- A dog bite at contact is a safety issue, and the fix can often be narrow. The court can attach a condition about the dog to a child arrangements order, so contact with the parent can carry on.
- Where an order sets the contact, do not simply keep your child at home. If the other parent seeks enforcement, you would have to prove a reasonable excuse for any contact you held back. Offer the safest contact you can and take advice quickly.
- With no order in place, try to agree the change in writing first. Failing that, use form C100 to seek a child arrangements order, asking for the condition in it, usually after a MIAM.
- Keep a record while it is fresh: the medical notes, photos of the wound as it heals, the other parent's messages kept whole, and your child's own words with the date. Do not question your child.
- Put the one change you need in writing to the other parent. If you cannot agree, a MIAM usually comes first, and after it form C100 asks for the order to be varied. You can ask for the condition as an interim order at the first hearing.
- A prohibited steps order is not the route where a condition on a child arrangements order can achieve the same result.
- An owner commits an offence if their dog is dangerously out of control anywhere in England or Wales, even at home. The exemption for homes applies only where the person at risk is, or is believed to be, a trespasser there. Reporting a bite to the police is a separate choice from asking the family court for a condition.
Checked and approved for publication by Iblal Iqbal.
Last reviewed .