A woman came to us with her late sister’s will. It named her as testamentary guardian of her sister’s young son, but the boy’s father said the will meant nothing while he was alive. He wanted his son home. This anonymised account sets out what we advised.
A guardian named in a will, and a father who said no
The parents had separated years earlier. Their son lived with his mother and saw his father most weekends. Both parents had parental responsibility, and neither had ever gone to court.
During her sister’s illness, the aunt did the school runs and the hospital visits. After the funeral, the boy stayed with her for a few weeks until his father asked for him back. She felt sure her sister had chosen her, and she was frightened of losing him too. If a will has named you in the same way, that fear makes sense.
When does a testamentary guardian take over?
Under section 5 of the Children Act 1989, a parent with parental responsibility can appoint a guardian for their child in the event of their death. The appointment must be in writing, dated and signed (section 5(5)), and a signed, dated will meets that test. Once it takes effect, the testamentary guardian holds parental responsibility under section 5(6).
Under section 5(7), the appointment takes effect on the death if no parent with parental responsibility is left. It also takes effect at once if, just before the death, a child arrangements order in force named the parent who died as a person the child was to live with. Section 5(9) disapplies that rule if the order also named the surviving parent as a person the child was to live with. Otherwise, section 5(8) applies, and the appointment waits until the child no longer has a parent with parental responsibility.
What our family law specialists advised
We started with the honest answer. The father had parental responsibility, and no order had ever named her sister. So the appointment had not taken effect. She was not yet her nephew’s guardian, and decisions about his home were for his father.
We then explained what she still had. While the boy was in her care, section 3(5) let her do what was reasonable to safeguard or promote his welfare. The appointment also stayed in the will, ready to take effect if he were ever left with no parent with parental responsibility.
His father threatened to ask the court to end the appointment, as anyone with parental responsibility may under section 6(7). We helped her write a calm reply explaining that it took nothing from him as a father while he lived.
We also advised her not to hold on to the boy. His welfare would be the court’s paramount consideration under section 1(1), and its checklist in section 1(3) asks how capable each parent is of meeting a child’s needs. His father had been there every week. A fight to keep the boy from him risked harming the child she wanted to protect.
Her route to the court
She wanted to stay in her nephew’s life. We advised her to agree a day for him to go home and to propose regular time with him in writing. His father would not commit. As she was not a parent or guardian, section 10(4) did not help her. Section 10(5) would have let her apply with the father’s consent, which he refused. So she needed the court’s permission.
Under section 10(9), the court looks at the nature of the application, her connection with the child and any risk of harmful disruption to his life. We helped her gather evidence of that connection, from the school runs to messages showing how often he asked for her. She applied with our guidance, asking only for time with him.
The outcome
At the first hearing, the court gave her permission to apply. The father then agreed terms, and the court made a child arrangements order by consent. The boy now spends alternate weekends and part of each school holiday with his aunt. His father let the appointment stand as a safety net. Every case turns on its own evidence, so this is not a promise about any other family.
What to take from this if you are a testamentary guardian
A will that names you does not always mean you step in at once. If the other parent has parental responsibility, the appointment usually waits. Check early whether a child arrangements order said the child lived with the parent who died, because that can change the answer.
Our guide to what happens to a child when a parent dies covers the wider picture. The legal guardianship guide sets out the ways to become a guardian, and our page on parental responsibility explains who holds it. For the court route, see our guide to child arrangements orders. You can also read how we prepare these success stories.
“While the appointment waits, your bond with the child still matters, so keep your time together regular and your messages to the surviving parent brief and civil. Ask the executor for a copy of the will and note its date. A later written appointment by the same parent replaces an earlier one, unless it was clearly meant to add a guardian, so check whether anything newer exists before you rely on it.”
Hannah Overton, Complex Children Specialist, Kabir Family Law
Talk it through with us
If a will names you as testamentary guardian, or a death has left your family arguing over a will, talk to us early. In a free, confidential initial consultation, tell us what the will says and who has parental responsibility. Our family law specialists will explain where you stand and what each option involves, with no obligation.
The legal issue
A mother died leaving a will that named her sister as guardian of her young son. The boy's parents had separated years before, both had parental responsibility, and neither had ever gone to court. The boy stayed with his aunt for a few weeks after the funeral. His father then asked for him to come home, wrote that the will meant nothing while he was alive, and said he would ask the court to cancel the appointment.
The law this rests on
- Children Act 1989 s.1(1): the child's welfare is the court's paramount consideration.
- Children Act 1989 s.1(3)(c) and (f): the welfare checklist includes the likely effect of any change in the child's circumstances, and how capable each parent, and any other relevant person, is of meeting the child's needs.
- Children Act 1989 s.3(5): a person who has care of a child but no parental responsibility may do what is reasonable in all the circumstances to safeguard or promote the child's welfare.
- Children Act 1989 s.5(3): a parent with parental responsibility may appoint another individual to be the child's guardian in the event of their death.
- Children Act 1989 s.5(5): the appointment has effect only if it is made in writing, is dated and is signed by the person making it, or is signed at their direction as s.5(5)(a) (a will, under section 9 of the Wills Act 1837) or s.5(5)(b) (in their presence and before two attesting witnesses) allows.
- Children Act 1989 s.5(6): a guardian appointed under section 5 has parental responsibility for the child.
- Children Act 1989 s.5(7): the appointment takes effect on the death if the child has no parent with parental responsibility, or if, immediately before the death, a child arrangements order in force named the person who died as a person with whom the child was to live, or the person who died was the child's only (or last surviving) special guardian.
- Children Act 1989 s.5(8): otherwise, the appointment takes effect when the child no longer has a parent with parental responsibility.
- Children Act 1989 s.5(9): the child arrangements order rule does not apply if the order also named a surviving parent as a person with whom the child was to live.
- Children Act 1989 s.6(7)(a): the court may bring an appointment of a guardian to an end on the application of any person with parental responsibility.
- Children Act 1989 s.8(1): a child arrangements order regulates with whom a child is to live, spend time or otherwise have contact, and when.
- Children Act 1989 s.10(4) and s.10(5)(c)(iii): who may apply for a section 8 order, or a child arrangements order, without the court's permission. Where no order says who the child lives with and the child is not in local authority care, that includes a person with the consent of everyone who has parental responsibility.
- Children Act 1989 s.10(9): when deciding permission, the court has particular regard to the nature of the application, the applicant's connection with the child and any risk of the application disrupting the child's life to the point of harm.
How we approached it
We first checked when the appointment would take effect. The father had parental responsibility and no child arrangements order had named the mother as a person the boy was to live with, so under Children Act 1989 s.5(8) the appointment had not taken effect. We told our client honestly that she was not yet the boy's guardian.
We explained that s.3(5) let her do what was reasonable for his welfare while he was in her care, and that the appointment remained in the will. We helped her write a calm reply to the father about the court's power under s.6(7) to end the appointment.
We advised her to agree a day for the boy to go home and to propose regular time with him in writing. When the father would not commit, we explained that she needed the court's permission to apply for a child arrangements order. We helped her gather evidence of her connection with the boy for the s.10(9) test, and guided her through an application that asked only for time with him.
The outcome
At the first hearing the court gave the aunt permission to apply. The father then agreed terms, and the court made a child arrangements order by consent for the boy to spend alternate weekends and part of each school holiday with his aunt. The father let the appointment stand, so it remains in the will as a safety net. Every case turns on its own evidence, and this is not a promise about any other family.
What to take from this
- A guardian named in a will does not always take over at once. If a surviving parent has parental responsibility, the appointment usually waits under Children Act 1989 s.5(8).
- The answer changes if, just before the death, a child arrangements order in force named the parent who died as a person the child was to live with, and did not also name the surviving parent in that way (s.5(7)(b) and s.5(9)).
- An appointment must be in writing, dated and signed (s.5(5)). A signed, dated will meets that test.
- Anyone with parental responsibility can ask the court to end an appointment (s.6(7)(a)).
- A relative who is not a parent or guardian usually needs the court's permission to apply for a child arrangements order. Where no order says who the child lives with and the child is not in local authority care, the consent of everyone with parental responsibility removes that need (s.10(5)(c)(iii)).
- Keep the child's welfare at the centre. A route back into the child's life can matter more than a fight over the will.
Checked and approved for publication by Iblal Iqbal.
Last reviewed .