Success story
Published 10 mins read11 sections

A father came to us when his daughter, now in her early teens, began asking to spend school nights at his home. Her mother did not agree, and his first idea was to “get her to tell the judge”. This anonymised account shows how our family law specialists helped her wishes and feelings reach the court properly, without putting her in the middle.

A daughter who had started to say what she wanted

The parents had separated when their daughter was small. A child arrangements order made then said she would live with her mother and spend alternate weekends with her father.

Secondary school changed her week. Her school and most of her friends were a short walk from her father’s home. She started asking to stay there on school nights, but her mother felt she was too young to decide.

Our client wanted his daughter to write to the judge, or to come to court with him. He feared that, if nobody asked her, the court would simply repeat an order made for a much younger child.

How a child’s wishes and feelings reach the court

The child’s welfare is the court’s paramount consideration under section 1 of the Children Act 1989. Section 1(3)(a) lists “the ascertainable wishes and feelings of the child concerned”, considered in the light of her age and understanding. The court must have regard to that checklist under section 1(4) when a party opposes varying a section 8 order. Here, the mother did.

Usually, the court hears from a child through Cafcass. Section 7 lets the court ask a Cafcass officer to report on matters relating to the child’s welfare, in writing or orally. Family Justice Council guidelines on judges meeting children say that, in most cases, a Cafcass officer brings a child’s wishes and feelings to the court in writing.

A judge can sometimes meet a child. However, those guidelines say the meeting is not for gathering evidence, and that the outcome is never the child’s responsibility.

How much weight does a teenager’s view carry? The welfare checklist sets no age at which a child’s view decides the case. The court weighs it alongside the other factors, including the likely effect of any change in her circumstances under section 1(3)(c).

What we advised, and why

First, we advised him not to coach his daughter or ask her to write anything for the court. A view that sounds rehearsed tends to lose its force. It would also leave her feeling she had to choose between her parents.

Next, we explained the route for relaying the child’s wishes and feelings. As a parent, he could apply without the court’s permission under section 10(4). He applied to vary the order on form C100, which GOV.UK says can be used for that, with our guidance.

We then helped him prepare to ask for a section 7 report at the first hearing. We kept the questions narrow: what his daughter wanted, how settled that wish was, and how a change would affect her school week.

His statement mattered too. We helped him keep it practical, from travel times to the school run. It proposed generous time with her mother, including a midweek evening and alternate weekends. That reflected section 1(2A). Where a parent can be involved safely, the court presumes, unless the contrary is shown, that their involvement will further the child’s welfare.

Finally, we prepared him for the talk at home. He told his daughter that the adults were sorting it out. Someone from Cafcass might want to hear what she thought. He did not discuss the case with her.

What the Cafcass officer heard about her wishes and feelings

The officer met her at school and spoke with both parents. Her wishes and feelings were clear, and had not changed over several months. Her reasons were practical, and she wanted to keep regular time with her mother. She did not want to meet the judge, but she asked the officer to pass her views on.

The officer recommended that she spend most school nights with her father. She would have alternate weekends and one midweek evening with her mother, with the holidays shared. Once the mother had read the report, she agreed. The court then made a varied child arrangements order on those terms. Both parents stayed fully involved, and their daughter knew she had been heard.

Every case turns on its own evidence, so this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from this if your child wants a say

Above all, keep your child out of the middle. Do not coach them, record them, or get them to write to the judge for you with their wishes and feelings. If a letter would help, the court can encourage one. Our guide to the role of Cafcass explains what the officer does.

Plan for both homes as well, keeping the other parent involved. Read more about how a child’s voice is heard, the role of a child guardian and how we prepare these success stories.

“Once a teenager’s school week changes, write to the school and ask it to keep both homes on its contact list. Department for Education guidance says staff must treat all parents equally unless a court order limits that. Plan a check after the first term on how the new week feels for them. Their views may shift again as they grow, and an agreed review is gentler on them than a fresh application.”

Hannah Overton, Complex Children Specialist, Kabir Family Law

Talk to us in confidence

If your child has started saying where they want to live, speak to us before you raise court with them. A free first consultation is confidential and carries no obligation. We can talk through whether to apply, what a section 7 report could cover and how your child’s wishes and feelings can be heard.

The legal issue

Separated parents had a child arrangements order, made when their daughter was small, under which she lived with her mother and spent alternate weekends with her father. In her early teens, with her school and most of her friends close to her father's home, she began asking to spend school nights there. Her mother disagreed and felt she was too young to decide. The father wanted to get his daughter to tell the judge herself, by writing to the judge or coming to court with him.

The law this rests on

  • Children Act 1989 s.1(1): the child's welfare is the court's paramount consideration.
  • Children Act 1989 s.1(2A) and s.1(6)(a): where a parent can be involved in the child's life without putting the child at risk of harm, the court presumes, unless the contrary is shown, that the parent's involvement will further the child's welfare.
  • Children Act 1989 s.1(2B): involvement means involvement of some kind, direct or indirect, but not any particular division of a child's time.
  • Children Act 1989 s.1(3)(a): the ascertainable wishes and feelings of the child, considered in the light of age and understanding.
  • Children Act 1989 s.1(3)(c): the likely effect on the child of any change in circumstances.
  • Children Act 1989 s.1(4)(a): the court must have regard to the welfare checklist when it is considering whether to vary a section 8 order and the variation is opposed by a party.
  • Children Act 1989 s.7(1) and s.7(3): the court may ask an officer of the Service (Cafcass) to report on matters relating to the child's welfare, in writing or orally.
  • Children Act 1989 s.8(2): a section 8 order includes any order varying or discharging a child arrangements order.
  • Children Act 1989 s.10(4)(a): a parent may apply for a section 8 order without the court's permission.
  • GOV.UK, form C100: the form can also be used to apply to vary or discharge an order.
  • Family Justice Council, Guidelines for Judges Meeting Children who are subject to Family Proceedings (April 2010, approved by the President of the Family Division): in most cases a Cafcass officer brings a child's wishes and feelings to the court in writing; a meeting with the judge is not for gathering evidence; a judge cannot hold secrets; the outcome is never the child's responsibility.

How we approached it

We advised the father not to coach his daughter, record her or ask her to write anything for the court, because a rehearsed view loses its force and would leave her feeling she had to choose between her parents.

We explained that the usual route for a child's wishes and feelings is a Cafcass officer reporting to the court under section 7 of the Children Act 1989. As a parent he needed no permission to apply (section 10(4)), and he applied to vary the existing order on form C100, with our guidance.

We helped him prepare to ask for a section 7 report with narrow questions: what his daughter wanted, how settled that wish was, and how a change would affect her school week and her time with her mother. We helped him write a practical statement that proposed generous time with her mother, in line with the presumption of parental involvement in section 1(2A). We also prepared him for what to say to his daughter at home, and what not to say.

The outcome

The Cafcass officer met the daughter at school and spoke with both parents. Her wish was clear and had not changed over several months. Her reasons were practical, and she wanted to keep regular time with her mother. She chose not to meet the judge but asked the officer to pass her views on. The officer recommended most school nights with her father, with alternate weekends, one midweek evening and shared holidays with her mother. The mother agreed after reading the report, and the court made a varied child arrangements order on those terms. Both parents stayed fully involved. Every case turns on its own evidence, and this is not a promise about any other family.

What to take from this

  • Keep your child out of the middle. Do not coach or record them, or get them to write to the judge for you.
  • The usual route for a child's wishes and feelings is a Cafcass officer reporting under section 7 of the Children Act 1989.
  • The welfare checklist sets no age at which a child's view decides the case. The court weighs it in the light of age and understanding, alongside the rest of the welfare checklist.
  • A judge may sometimes meet a child, but the meeting is not for gathering evidence and the outcome is never the child's responsibility.
  • As a parent you can apply to vary an existing order without permission, using form C100.
  • Propose arrangements that keep both parents involved. Where a parent can be involved safely, the law presumes that involvement furthers the child's welfare, without fixing any division of time.

Checked and approved for publication by Iblal Iqbal.

Last reviewed .

Read more about this area of family law

Child’s Voice in Custody Proceedings

Author:

Hannah Overton is a complex children specialist at Kabir Family Law, focusing on child arrangements disputes, fact‑finding hearings and cases involving CAFCASS and safeguarding concerns in the family courts of England and Wales. She has extensive experience supporting parents through allegation‑heavy proceedings and creates clear, practical resources that explain court processes, evidence preparation and contact arrangements. Hannah also works closely with the client services team to ensure families receive informed, compassionate guidance at every stage of their case.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Not sure where to start?

Type a topic to see the pages that cover it, or choose one below.

Or choose a topic

Or call us on 0330 094 5880

Find your nearest Kabir Family Law Office and arrange meeting

Contact us to arrange a meeting